Best Smart Scales for 2024

The WYZE Smart Scale X receives a moderate score, praised for its affordability, stylish design, and ability to track multiple health metrics, making it suitable for casual users. However, criticisms regarding the app's functionality—such as slow response times and lack of detailed metrics—alongside inconsistencies in body fat percentage readings, indicate room for improvement in user experience.

The Fitbit FB203BK Aria Air Smart Scale garners a moderate score due to its accurate weight measurements and ease of setup, appealing particularly to existing Fitbit users. However, many users express frustration over inconsistent connectivity and the requirement of having the app open during weigh-ins, which detracts from its smart capabilities. While it is a good fit within the Fitbit ecosystem, potential buyers not already integrated into this environment might find better alternatives at similar price points.

The Garmin Index S2 receives a moderate score, primarily due to its premium build quality and ability to track a variety of health metrics, making it appealing for dedicated fitness enthusiasts. However, many users report frustrating connectivity issues with the Garmin Connect app and inconsistencies in body composition measurements, questioning the overall value given its high price point.

The Withings Body Cardio scale earns a moderate score, celebrated for its sleek design, innovative heart health metrics, and robust app integration that many users find valuable for health tracking. However, concerns over the reliability of heart rate measurements and inconsistent performance have been noted, along with disappointing customer service experiences. While it offers advanced features, some customers argue that these do not justify the higher price point compared to simpler, less expensive models.