Best Mandolin Picks for 2024

We analyzed top picks from leading reviewers to find the best for every need
Published: June 26th, 2024

🎶Finding the right mandolin pick can really change your playing experience. Whether you're just starting out or have been playing for years, the right pick can affect your tone, technique, and overall performance.

After digging deep into the options, we've rounded up some of the best mandolin picks out there, considering things like material, shape, and what other players had to say. This way, you're more likely to find a pick that feels just right for your mandolin.

🥇
Overall Best: D'Addario 2CA7-01CT

The D'Addario 2CA7-01CT stands out as our overall best pick for its exceptional versatility and quality construction. Crafted from casein, it strikes an ideal balance between grip and flexibility, making it suitable for everything from fast-paced tunes to softer melodies. The triangular shape provides excellent control and precision, benefiting players of all skill levels. According to our research, users appreciate its comfortable feel and the rich, full sound it produces. Whether you're strumming or picking, the D'Addario 2CA7-01CT is a stellar choice for mandolin players.

Available at Amazon
View at Amazon

🥈
Runner-up: Dunlop 512P140

Dunlop 512P Primetone TRIANGLE Sculpted Plectra with Grip, 3-Pack 1.50 mm

Our runner-up, the Dunlop 512P140, is celebrated for its durability and bright sound. Made from Ultex, this triangular pick enhances control, particularly during high-speed strumming sessions. Its thickness contributes to consistent play, making it an excellent option for both rhythm and solo performances. Many professionals favor this pick for its robust sound and reliable performance, positioning it as a strong contender to our top choice. If you're looking for a dependable pick that delivers a clear, vibrant tone, the Dunlop 512P140 is a fantastic alternative.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$9.49 at Sweetwater

More Answers

Still curious about the Dunlop Primetone Triangle Picks (3-Pack)? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

🎸
Are Dunlop 512P Primetone TRIANGLE picks good for bass guitar?
Thinking about giving the Dunlop 512P Primetone Triangle picks a shot for your bass guitar? You're not alone—lots of musicians talk these up for their grip and sound. **Design and Features** The manufacturer mentions that these picks are made from Ultex, which is known for being durable and having great sound qualities. They've got something called Primetone embossing, which is pretty low-profile and keeps the pick steady in your fingers. Plus, the edges are hand-burnished, so you might find it easier to play fast riffs or strum at different speeds. **What We Found** From what we've gathered, these picks get a lot of love for their grip and sound. People say they feel firm but not too heavy and are comparable to some other top-notch picks like the [PickBoy ultex](https://www.shopsavvy.com/redirect?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.amazon.com%2Fs%3Fk%3DPickBoy%2Bultex%26tag%3Dssw.ans.tx-1-20). You might even notice how clearly they transfer power to the strings, giving you a loud, clear sound with less pick noise—a big plus if you want those bass notes to really stand out. And they're not just for one type of music. Whether you're into rock, jazz, or even something like bluegrass, according to our research, they tend to work well. **What To Keep In Mind** Of course, everyone has their own preferences! While many folks seem to really like what these picks offer, at least one person felt they weren't great for acoustic playing, calling them a bit flimsy with not quite the tone they wanted. **Wrap-up** So, while these picks might cost a bit more than the usual ones, they generally get good feedback for grip, tone, and versatility. It could be worth it to try them out for yourself and see how they fit with your bass playing style!
🎸
Do Dunlop 512P Primetone TRIANGLE picks slip out of your hand easily?
Wondering if the Dunlop 512P Primetone Triangle picks tend to slip out of your hand? From what we've gathered, most folks are pretty satisfied with how these picks stay put. They're 1.50 mm thick and built to be both durable and grippy. The manufacturer describes them as having a low-profile grip with Primetone-embossing, which is designed to enhance control and minimize slipping. This can really help during quick, precise playing and smooth strumming. According to our research, people generally highlight this grip as a significant advantage. One person even mentioned it's the only pick that hasn't slipped or dropped from their hand. Another user commented on how natural and comfortable the textured grip felt, especially during long sessions. Backing this up, the picks average a solid 4.4 out of 5 stars, with many reviews praising their grip and control. It seems like if a non-slip grip is important to you, these picks have got you covered. That said, experiences can vary. Some musicians mentioned taking some time to adjust to their size and texture, particularly if they're used to other pick styles. But overall, if you're looking for a pick that offers a reliable grip, especially for those fast-paced sessions or relaxed strumming, the Dunlop 512P Primetone Triangle picks could be a great fit for you.
🎸
How do Dunlop 512P Primetone TRIANGLE picks compare to Blue Chip picks?
When you're weighing Dunlop 512P Primetone Triangle picks against [Blue Chip picks](https://www.shopsavvy.com/redirect?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.amazon.com%2Fs%3Fk%3Dblue%2Bchip%2Bpicks%26tag%3Dssw.ans.tx-1-20), there are a few things worth considering to determine which might suit your playing style and preferences. **Materials and Durability** Dunlop 512P Primetone Triangle Picks are made from Ultex—a pretty tough material known for its clear sound and longevity. From what we found, these picks hold up well over time, even with heavy use. On the other hand, Blue Chip picks are made from a special composite material meant to feel like tortoise shell. Many players love them for their unique mix of warmth and clarity, and they're also highly durable. Just keep in mind, Blue Chips are pricier, reflecting their higher-end status. **Grip and Playability** Both pick brands score high on grip. Dunlop Primetones have a larger gripping surface because of their triangle shape, plus they come with embossed text that helps with grip, especially during fast or complex playing. Our data shows a lot of musicians appreciate this stability. Blue Chip picks, meanwhile, are often lauded for their smooth, ergonomic feel, which remains comfortable during long playing sessions. **Tone and Sound Quality** The tonal qualities of these picks also set them apart. Primetone picks are known for their crisp tones and low pick noise. Those who've tried them often praise the clear, articulate sound. They come with beveled edges, which are great for smooth strumming and precise picking. Blue Chip picks, however, are loved for their warm and articulate tone, often blending beautifully with an instrument's natural sound. **User Feedback and Popularity** Our research shows both picks have loyal user bases. Some players might lean towards the more budget-friendly Dunlop 512P Primetone, appreciating both its durability and tone. But if you're tempted by a premium option and don't mind spending a bit more, Blue Chip picks have a strong reputation for excellence among those who use them. In the end, deciding between Dunlop Primetone and Blue Chip picks is really about what you value more in terms of tone, grip, and budget. Both are solid picks, so trying each might help you figure out which one suits your style best.
View All Answers for

💸
Budget Pick: Fender 346

If you’re searching for a budget-friendly option without sacrificing quality, the Fender 346 is an excellent pick. Manufactured from celluloid, this pick offers a strong, resonant sound appreciated by many players. Its thicker profile and pointed tip provide precision that suits various playing styles. Despite its affordable price, it maintains a high standard of quality, making it our top budget pick for mandolin players. The Fender 346 proves that you don't need to overspend to achieve great sound and performance.

Available at Amazon
View at Amazon

Best for Beginners: D'Addario 2AN7-03

D'Addario Accessories by D'Addario Accessories 2AN7-03 Acrylux Guitar Picks, Mandolin 1.5MM, 3-Pack, Nitra

For beginners, the D'Addario 2AN7-03 is the perfect pick due to its ideal shape and softer feel. Made from nitra acrylic, it guarantees articulate sound while offering long-lasting durability. This pick is especially well-suited for playing chords and rhythm sections, providing a comfortable and enjoyable playing experience. Its affordability and user-friendly design make it the best option for new mandolin players looking to get a good start with a reliable pick.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$16.50 at Amazon

More Answers

Still curious about the D'Addario Acrylux Guitar Picks (1.5MM, 3-Pack)? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

🎶
Do D'Addario Acrylux Nitra 2AN7-03 picks produce a warmer tone on mandolin?
If you're hoping for a warmer tone on your mandolin, the D'Addario Acrylux Nitra 2AN7-03 picks might be worth checking out. Made from an acrylic/nitrate hybrid, they're designed to give a rich, rounded sound without losing clarity. According to our research, a lot of mandolin players have found that these picks improve playability. They seem to hit a sweet spot with weight and size, making them comfortable and easy to use. Many musicians have noted that these picks make their mandolin playing smoother and more enjoyable. One person mentioned they preferred them over standard guitar picks because of the warm tone. Another tried various picks and settled on these as their top choice due to the smooth, warm sound they produce. The picks are also noted for their durability and grip, which help create a strong sound. The burnished edges, as highlighted by the manufacturer, help the picks glide across strings, reducing unwanted clicking noises—great for genres that require clean sound or fast techniques like tremolo. However, it's worth mentioning that not everyone feels the same—pick preference is pretty subjective. Some folks found they didn’t quite match their personal style or preference, so it’s useful to consider how they might work with your playing technique. All in all, if you're exploring different sounds on your mandolin, giving the D'Addario Acrylux Nitra 2AN7-03 picks a try could be a good move. They blend quality with thoughtful design, making them versatile for various genres like bluegrass or classical.
🎶
What is the thickness of the D'Addario Acrylux Nitra 2AN7-03 mandolin picks?
The D'Addario Acrylux Nitra 2AN7-03 mandolin picks are 1.5mm thick. The manufacturer describes these picks as being made with a special acrylic/nitrate hybrid that gives them a warm tone and good grip. From our research, these picks are generally well-liked by mandolin players. Many appreciate their comfortable weight and size, which seem to make them easier to handle. People also tend to like the smooth edges and the slightly darker tone, which gives a softer sound compared to some other picks out there. That said, not everyone finds them perfect for mandolin use—preferences vary, after all. But overall, the feedback is positive, with a lot of players noting the enhanced sound and feel they get with these picks. If you’re thinking about trying them, these picks offer good grip and tone quality for different styles, and most mandolin players seem to enjoy them.
🎶
How do D'Addario Acrylux Nitra picks compare to standard guitar picks for mandolin?
If you're wondering how D'Addario Acrylux Nitra picks stack up against regular guitar picks for playing mandolin, here's what we've found. These Acrylux Nitra picks are made from a unique mix of acrylic and nitrate. This combo is designed to give your mandolin a warm but clear tone, which is super important when you're trying to get that beautiful, nuanced sound. Our research shows that a lot of mandolin players really like the improved tone compared to the usual guitar picks. When it comes to comfort and how they feel when you play, these picks hit the mark. They have the right amount of thickness to feel solid without being too stiff, making them comfortable for long sessions and giving you better control over your strumming and picking. Another cool thing about the Acrylux Nitra picks is how smoothly they move across the strings. This helps cut down on that annoying clicking sound, especially when you're doing quick techniques like tremolo. A smooth pick glide can really make a difference. Grip is also a big plus here. These picks are made to stay put in your hand, even during intense playing. Our data points out that players appreciate the reliable grip combined with the acrylic material, which means consistent performance and sound. Of course, everyone has their own pick preferences. While many folks praise the Acrylux picks for their warm tone, precision, and stability, some might prefer something softer. But if you're after picks that offer extra warmth, a unique material blend, and a solid grip for your mandolin playing, the D'Addario Acrylux Nitra picks are definitely worth trying out. So, if you're aiming to boost your mandolin playing with better comfort and sound quality, these picks are a good option compared to standard guitar picks.
View All Answers for

Best for Versatility: PRS Tortoise Celluloid

PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack

The PRS Tortoise Celluloid is the go-to choice for musicians seeking versatility. This pick mimics the classic tortoiseshell picks but is crafted from modern celluloid materials, delivering a beautiful tone ideal for intricate fingerpicking. Its standard shape makes it highly versatile, perfect for use with both mandolins and guitars. For those who play multiple instruments or engage in varied playing styles, the PRS Tortoise Celluloid offers maximum flexibility without compromising sound quality or performance.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$11.98 at Amazon

More Answers

Still curious about the PRS Celluloid Picks Medium? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

🎸
What material are PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack made of?
The PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack are made from celluloid. According to the manufacturer's product description, this material has been popular with musicians for quite a while because of its durability and the warm, full sound it produces. These picks are medium thickness, which provides a good balance of flexibility and control. This means they're easy to hold and give you just the right amount of give for different playing styles. Our research also suggests that they have smooth edges, making it easier to play across strings without snagging—handy for those long jam sessions. Visually, they have that classic tortoise shell look, which gives them a bit of vintage charm. Plus, there's the PRS Private Stock eagle imprint, which adds a bit of flair to your guitar gear. From what we've found, people using these picks say they last a long time, even with frequent use. They've generally received high marks from those who've tried them out, which suggests they're doing something right in both performance and style. So whether you’re strumming or shredding, these picks seem like a solid choice to support your playing style. Enjoy making music!
🎸
Are PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack suitable for different playing styles?
Hey! If you're looking for guitar picks that play nice with different styles, the PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack might be worth checking out. These picks are made of celluloid, which is known for its warm tone and durability, and they come in a medium thickness that balances flex and stability pretty well. Our research suggests that they handle a variety of techniques, whether you're strumming chords or picking out single notes. People seem to like how smoothly they glide across the strings, making it a good pick for both speedy solos and mellow fingerpicking. Apparently, they also hold up well during long sessions, keeping a stable grip – which is super important if you're jamming for a while or playing live. Just a heads-up, they don't come with pick holders. So if you're someone who likes to keep things tidy, you might need to grab a holder separately. But all in all, they sound like a solid choice for guitarists with diverse styles. Enjoy your playing!
🎸
What is the thickness of PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack?
The PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack is a solid choice if you're into mixing up your playing style. According to the manufacturer's product description, these picks are made from celluloid, which is known for giving a warm, full tone. It's pretty versatile, fitting well with both strumming and picking techniques. From our research, we've found that people appreciate the good grip and responsiveness of these picks. This is super helpful, especially if you frequently switch between strumming chords and picking melodies. The smooth edges make it easier for the pick to glide across the strings without getting caught. As for the thickness, these are medium picks. Our data indicates that this medium thickness strikes a nice balance between flexibility and control. It provides enough give for strumming, while still being sturdy enough for precise lead work. So, whether you're strumming or picking, these should have you covered. Overall, if you want picks that combine flexibility with durability and sound great, the PRS Celluloid Picks Tortoise Medium 12-Pack is definitely worth considering. They offer good functionality and cater to various playing techniques, making them a reliable option for both beginners and seasoned guitarists.
View All Answers for
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

🥇 ShopSavvy Best Picks
Expert recommendations for the best overall, budget, and specialized product picks.
Our researchers bring you our top recommendations. Each article usually highlights the best overall choice, a budget-friendly option, and picks for specific needs, helping you shop smarter and with confidence.

Explore Content

More to Explore

Best Jaw Harps in 2024
BEST PICKS

Best Jaw Harps in 2024

September 26th 2024
How does the Bigsby tremolo system work on the Gretsch G2420T?
ANSWER

How does the Bigsby tremolo system work on the Gretsch G2420T?

September 25th 2024

Latest Deals

Free Nintendo Winter Magazine!
A
95/100

Free Nintendo Winter Magazine!

2 minutes ago
56% Off Studio Ghibli 6-Film Collection!
A
95/100

56% Off Studio Ghibli 6-Film Collection!

7 minutes ago

Published

Legal

Subscribe for Updates

Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!

TwitterInstagramFacebook

© 2024 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..