TLDR Review: The Paragon Hotel
Pros
- •The novel is richly researched, offering vivid and authentic details of 1920s America, especially Portland and Harlem.
- •It explores complex social issues like racism, segregation, the rise of the KKK in Oregon, and institutionalized racism with nuance and impressive depth.
- •Strong, weleveloped characters—particularly the protagonist Alice James, a white gun moll fleeing the New York mafia—drive a compelling personal and emotional journey.
- •The Paragon Hotel itself is portrayed as a unique cultural oasis for people of color, blending hospitality with hidden layers of protection and surveillance.
- •The story includes memorable and nuanced characters, including heroic women and complex male figures, enhancing the narrative’s emotional and thematic richness.
- •Themes of feminism and female empowerment emerge subtly through strong female characters taking control of their lives.
- •The plot is complex and engaging, weaving in love stories and unexpected twists that leave a lasting impact.
- •The author’s writing style is graceful and immersive, with historically accurate dialogue and vivid scenetting that transport readers to another era.
- •Readers from Portland and the Pacific Northwest may find extra connection through the detailed local historical context.
- •The narrative deftly combines historical context with personal drama, creating an enlightening and soulful reading experience.
Cons
- •The story can be slow to gain momentum, only picking up pace around 60% in, which may frustrate readers looking for an immediate hook.
- •The vernacular and style may sometimes be challenging, requiring rereading to fully grasp certain sections.
- •Some readers felt the storyline would have been more engaging if it focused more on Blossom’s earlier life rather than the later timeline.
- •Despite strong historical and emotional layers, the book may not captivate every reader quickly or strongly.
- •Certain brutal or vivid scenes related to racial tension and survival might feel heavy for some.
Bottom Line
*The Paragon Hotel* is a deeply researched and emotionally rich historical novel that shines a spotlight on difficult, rarely explored aspects of 1920s Oregon and racial history in America. While its deliberate pacing and complex language might not suit everyone’s taste, it rewards patient readers with memorable characters, a gripping plot, and insightful social commentary. If you appreciate nuanced historical fiction that doesn’t shy away from hard truths and character-driven storytelling, this novel is a compelling choice. However, if you want something faster-paced or less dense, you might want to browse other historical fiction options.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!