Pros

  • โ€ขSuperior taste, texture, and consistency make Teddie Peanut Butter a standout choice.
  • โ€ขOnly two ingredients, peanuts and salt, ensure a truly natural product.
  • โ€ขLess sugary and free from additives, which is a healthier option.
  • โ€ขCreamy texture with a true peanut flavor is appreciated by users.
  • โ€ขMinimal separation and easy to mix and spread compared to other natural brands.
  • โ€ขPraised as a great value for an alatural peanut butter.
  • โ€ขStirs up easily and doesnโ€™t require refrigeration, enhancing convenience.
  • โ€ขSimple ingredient list with no fillers or unnecessary ingredients.
  • โ€ขSpreads smoothly and suits a variety of uses, like protein boost or thickening.

Cons

  • โ€ขStirring the oil for a smooth texture can be challenging.
  • โ€ขSome find the flavor lacks the strong roasted peanut taste.
  • โ€ขOccasionally dries at the bottom and requires periodic stirring.
  • โ€ขConsistency is runnier than processed options but remains usable.
  • โ€ขDescribed as bland by some, though not offensive, and underwhelming in taste.

Bottom Line

Teddie Smooth Old Fashioned All Natural Peanut Butter is highly rated for its simple, natural ingredients and pleasing texture. Though some find it lacks a strong roasted flavor, its ease of use and healthy composition make it a favorite among those seeking a more natural peanut butter. If youโ€™re after a healthier option without unnecessary additives, Teddie is a sound choice.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$5.59 at Instacart

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: June 27th 2025 9:50 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
๐Ÿ›’
A+

50% Off Two $40+ Grocery Orders!

3 minutes ago
50% Off 3-Pack Syrinx Biker Shorts!
A

50% Off 3-Pack Syrinx Biker Shorts!

2 minutes ago

ยฉ 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..