💭 ShopSavvy TLDR Reviews

Expertly researched reviews about products you're interested in, condensed down to a score, pros/cons and a bottom line.

🔥 Trending Deals

Loading trending deals...

Reynolds Wrap Non Stick Aluminum Foil, Nonstick Aluminum Foil Roll, Prevents Food Sticking and Messy Cleanup, Great for Covering Casseroles and leftovers, 43.33 Yards x 12 Inches, 130 Sq.Ft.

TLDR Review: Reynolds Wrap Nonstick Aluminum Foil

Item: Reynolds Wrap Nonstick Aluminum Foil
Author: ShopSavvy

By ShopSavvy Team

Published: March 10th, 2025

Pros

•Highly effective as a toaster oven liner, outperforming traditional aluminum foil.
•Works well with oily foods; no sticking issues even with fish filets.
•The notick coating is a silicone polymer, considered safe for cooking.
•Easy to clean; debris can often be rinsed off with hot water for reuse.
•Enhances the longevity of toaster oven trays and simplifies cleanup.
•Excellent notick properties; nothing adheres to it.
•Ideal for foods that typically stick to aluminum foil.
•Prevents food items from burning and allows for easier cooking.
•Can be used as insulation for heat from toasters and countertop ovens.
•Ideal for lining oven crumb trays, making cleaning much easier.

Cons

•Posandemic, the foil's thickness has decreased significantly, making it fragile.
•The regular version is extremely thin and prone to ripping during use.
•No improvement in thickness has been noted; only a price increase has occurred.
•Recent purchases have a significant decline in quality compared to previous rolls.
•Food consistently sticks to the foil despite the expectation of notick performance.
•Necessitates the use of spray or oil to prevent sticking, which defeats the purpose.
•Users express a desire for the previous thicker formula to be reinstated.
•The nonstick surface does not perform as well as it used to, leading to food sticking.

Bottom Line

Reynolds Wrap Non Stick Aluminum Foil is a versatile kitchen tool, praised for its non-stick properties and ease of cleaning. However, many users have noted a disappointing decline in quality, with thinner foil and less effective non-stick performance post-pandemic. If durability and quality are crucial for your cooking needs, you might want to consider alternative options or look for heavier duty versions by Reynolds.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer

$8.99 at Amazon