Pros
- •Gentle on the eyes, suitable for contact lens wearers, with no flaking or irritation.
- •Applies perfectly from the first use, with no need for excessive wiping or multiple applications.
- •No clumping or flaking, staying intact throughout the day and night.
- •Leaves lashes feeling lightweight and natural, providing a false lash effect.
- •Provides a natural look with added length and volume.
- •Glossy black color is visually appealing and stands out from other blacks.
- •Easily washes off with baby wipes, eliminating the need for harsh removal methods.
- •Ideal for quick application with no infections, enhancing the lash appearance.
- •Excellent volume and definition without smudging; stays put well throughout the day.
- •Larger brush size preferred for easy application.
Cons
- •Experienced some smudging, even with a single coat application.
- •Recent new formula is less effective, clumping easily and feeling hard when dried.
- •Does not curl or lengthen lashes effectively; limited noticeable length.
- •Advertised for sensitive eyes but caused irritation and watery eyes for some users.
- •Recent purchases reported as slightly dried out, affecting performance.
- •Product contents found to be lacking, making application difficult and requiring effort.
Bottom Line
The Neutrogena Cosmetics Healthy Volume Mascara in Black (02) is praised for offering a natural look with impressive volume while being gentle on the eyes. It is particularly suitable for contact lens wearers. Some users, however, reported dissatisfaction with a recent formula change, finding it less effective and prone to clumping. If sensitive eyes and smudging are concerns, check its effectiveness with a small trial or consider alternatives that offer specialized formulas for sensitive conditions.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!