TLDR Review: Moen PosiTemp Cartridge
Verdict
This replacement cartridge can be a dependable fix if you’re confident you're installing a genuine Moen part. While it offers ease of installation and good longevity when trusted, many reviews flag concerns about counterfeit units, short shelf life, and immediate failures, which could turn your repair into a costly hassle. We recommend verifying the authenticity before purchase or considering official Moen cartridges to avoid plumbing headaches. If you're looking for a more reliable option with verified authenticity, checking <component-button-product + identifierProduct=
- Top pro:
- Easy to install replacement for stiff shower faucet cartridges, with smooth operation once installed properly.
- Top con:
- Some units appear to be non-authentic or replica, causing serious quality concerns.
Pros
- •Easy to install replacement for stiff shower faucet cartridges, with smooth operation once installed properly.
- •Replaced a legacy part that lasted 13 years, indicating good longevity.
- •Initially functions well, saving users from potential frustration if installed correctly.
- •Good value for the money, especially as a replacement part.
- •Quick and straightforward installation with proper insertion.
- •Available online with tutorial resources that can assist first-timers.
- •Excellent customer service response from the seller.
- •Replaces the original part, restoring proper faucet operation.
- •When genuine, prevents water hammer issues and leaks.
- •Designed for Moen tub and shower configurations, compatible with many fixtures.
Cons
- •Some units appear to be non-authentic or replica, causing serious quality concerns.
- •Immediate leaks and failures occurred upon installation in some cases.
- •Short shelf life of only six months according to Moen, which is a significant drawback.
- •The high cost at $45 makes it an expensive fix if faulty or low-quality.
- •Several reviews mention persistent water hammer, banging noises, and leaking despite proper installation.
- •Problems with cold water only and ongoing leaks suggest possible design or compatibility issues.
- •Limited availability of genuine parts locally; some units may be counterfeit or low quality.
- •Water hammer issues were resolved only after switching to authentic Moen parts.
- •The product often does not match official Moen branding and packaging.
- •Installing non-genuine cartridges can cause plumbing noise issues and potential damage.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
How we researched this
About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
