TLDR Review: Maybelline TattooStudio Eyeliner - Smokey Black
Verdict
This Maybelline TattooStudio Liner Gel Pencil offers impressive longevity and bold color, making it a solid choice for waterproof, smudgeproof eyeliner — especially if you need all-day wear. However, its quick setting time and initial smudging may require some mastering, and it might not perform as well on the waterline as some reviews suggest. If you're looking for an eyeliner with guaranteed staying power on waterlines, you might want to consider a product specifically designed for that purpose. For a similar, highly-rated option that performs better on waterlines, check out the <component-button-product identifierProduct="12345-67890...">.
- Top pro:
- Long-lasting and waterproof, stays on without smudging or fading throughout the day
- Top con:
- Can smudge initially but tends to become patchy if disturbed after drying
Pros
- •Long-lasting and waterproof, stays on without smudging or fading throughout the day
- •Deep black, vibrant color that offers a bold, matte finish
- •Easy to apply with smooth, precise lines, and a twist-up design for prolonged use
- •Performs well along the waterline, providing clean and defined application
- •Reliable for sensitive eyes, with no reported irritation from reviews
- •Similar in quality to high-end brands like Urban Decay, offering professional results
- •Applies smoothly and blends well initially, allowing for versatile looks
- •Particularly praised for its pigment intensity and rich color payoff
- •Comes in a convenient mechanical pencil form, making it user-friendly and portable
- •Good value considering its durability and performance over 36 hours
Cons
- •Can smudge initially but tends to become patchy if disturbed after drying
- •Requires prompt blending; if left unmoved, it sets quickly and becomes difficult to smudge
- •Not ideal for using with a smudging tool, as it's formulated for a no-budge, tattoo-like finish
- •Some reviews mention it fades within 30 minutes on the waterline, which is disappointing for waterproof claims
- •The color may sometimes appear lighter or different than expected, especially on certain skin tones (e.g., light brown instead of charcoal)
- •Slight initial smudging can occur, which may be frustrating for precise eyeliner
- •If you prefer a softer, more smudged look, it might not be the best, as it dries quickly
- •Limited information on removal—may require makeup remover to fully take off
- •The product may need sharpening over time, despite being twist-up, for finer lines
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
How we researched this
About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from 3 retailers in ShopSavvy's price data, most recently seen Oct 29, 2026.
Where to Buy
| Retailer | Price | Last seen | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| $5.31 | Nov 29, 2024 may have changed | ||
| $8.53 | Oct 29, 2026 |
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
