Pros

  • Excellent lonasting wear that stays intact for over 15 hours, making it perfect for extended days
  • Dries to a comfortable matte finish after initial stickiness
  • Can be layered with balm for a softer, noatte look
  • Maintains a natural, "my lips but better" tone that enhances the lips
  • Stays on through eating, drinking, and talking without fading or cracking
  • Easy to apply smoothly and evenly, with a vibrant, natural color
  • Remains comfortable once fully dry, despite an initial sticky feeling
  • Versatile shades like "Mascara Tear" and "Ribbon Tied" suit various seasons and occasions
  • Very effective at providing a stain that survives straw drinking and messy eating
  • Easy to remove when needed, despite its long wear

Cons

  • Initial drying phase involves a sticky or tacky feeling that lasts about an hour
  • The product can appear darker than expected when first applied, which might be surprising
  • Takes over an hour to fully dry, potentially inconvenient for those in a hurry
  • Some users experienced dryness or tightness on the lips during wear
  • The shade matching online can be tricky, making it difficult to select the perfect color without seeing it in person
  • The initial stickiness may be ofutting for some, though it fades with time
  • Slightly difficult to choose the right shade solely based on online images

Bottom Line

This Maybelline Super Stay Teddy Lip Tint offers impressive long-lasting wear with a natural, matte finish, ideal for all-day activities. While it has a slow dry time and some initial stickiness, its reliable staying power makes it a great choice. Those seeking quicker drying might consider other options within the Maybelline Super Stay line.

How we researched this

About this review: We pulled together findings from professional reviews and hundreds of user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.

Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy AppDownload ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser ExtensionInstall ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

a month ago
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

a month ago