Pros

  • β€’Many users report switching to this mascara from their previous favorites, praising the formula.
  • β€’Described as delivering 'beautiful' and 'stunning' results with naturaooking eyelashes.
  • β€’Offers impressive performance in thickening and lengthening lashes.
  • β€’The True Brown color is appealing and complements corresponding eyeliner.
  • β€’Easy to remove with soap or other makeup removers, and doesn’t cause lash breakage.
  • β€’Highly recommended for those seeking longer lashes, potentially receiving compliments.
  • β€’Consistent good pigmentation and causes no irritation.
  • β€’Does not clump or overdry, making it suitable for mature users.
  • β€’Provides stunning, enhanced eyelash appearance either with curled or straight lashes.

Cons

  • β€’Brush design may create marks above and below the lash line, complicating application.
  • β€’Some users have unmet expectations, finding it not as effective as claimed.
  • β€’Difficulty in complete removal despite being marketed as washable.
  • β€’Formula might feel watery and ineffective for some, impacting curl maintenance.
  • β€’In certain cases, struggles to maintain lash curl, causing lashes to fall quickly.
  • β€’Some users report the need for additional makeup remover for complete removal.

Bottom Line

Maybelline New York Sky High Washable Mascara in True Brown is a standout product for those looking to volumize and lengthen their lashes with a natural finish. While many users have praised its easy removal and beautiful results, a few have noted issues with application and complete removal despite its washable claim. For those seeking dramatic lash enhancement without clumps or irritation, this mascara is a strong contender, provided you don't mind a little extra effort in the removal process.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$9.25 at Amazon

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: July 24th 2025 2:01 am
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
🎬
C

Galaxy Quest 4K UHD + Digital

14 days ago
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
πŸ“€
B

Galaxy Quest 4K UHD Deal!

14 days ago

Β© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..