TLDR Review: MaraNatha Organic Peanut Butter
Verdict
If you prioritize a creamy, delicious peanut butter flavor and don't mind the packaging switch, MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter still delivers on taste. However, the shockingly runny consistency and plastic jar instead of the promised glass make this product less ideal for traditional spread lovers or those committed to reducing plastic waste. The packaging downgrade is a dealbreaker for many, which overshadows the peanut butter’s otherwise rich flavor. If you want the classic creamy texture in environmentally friendly glass, or a thicker spread without the runniness, it’s worth exploring other organic options that maintain glass packaging and firmer consistencies.
- Top pro:
- The taste of MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is widely described as delicious and rich, appealing to those who enjoy a creamy peanut butter with a touch of sea salt.
- Top con:
- The product is advertised as coming in a glass jar but is actually packaged in plastic, causing frustration and feelings of misleading advertising for about 90% of reviewers.
Pros
- •The taste of MaraNatha Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is widely described as delicious and rich, appealing to those who enjoy a creamy peanut butter with a touch of sea salt.
- •Many users appreciate that this product requires minimal stirring compared to other natural peanut butters.
- •The flavor is indulgent enough to be paired with treats like dark chocolate or even a glass of champagne, lending a luxurious experience.
- •The ultra-smooth, velvety texture is ideal for dipping and spreading when the product is at the right temperature.
Cons
- •The product is advertised as coming in a glass jar but is actually packaged in plastic, causing frustration and feelings of misleading advertising for about 90% of reviewers.
- •The plastic jars lead to a runny, thin consistency where the oil separates quickly, making it more like syrup and difficult to spread smoothly.
- •Plastic containers hold temperature poorly, contributing to the oil separation and need for frequent stirring.
- •The plastic lids and glue seals are often hard to open and sometimes leave residue or foil fragments.
- •Long-time fans of the brand are disappointed by the switch from recyclable and reusable glass jars to plastic, raising concerns about potential microplastics and environmental impact.
- •The runny consistency at room temperature reduces usability on foods like crackers and sandwiches.
- •Some users feel the taste is somewhat compromised by the packaging change and wish for fewer ingredients like competing organic brands.
- •A handful mention quality control issues such as leaking jars or an unusual taste, which adds to the hesitance in repurchasing.
- •The packaging discrepancy and plastic concerns contribute to a perception of false advertising.
- •Some find it less cost-effective compared to similar organic peanut butters on the market.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
How we researched this
About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from 1 retailer in ShopSavvy's price data, most recently seen Oct 12, 2026.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
