Pros

  • โ€ขConsidered the best peanut butter available, with strong recommendations from repeat purchasers.
  • โ€ขMade with Valencia peanuts, which are praised for superior taste.
  • โ€ขProvides excellent value, especially for organic peanut butter.
  • โ€ขTasty flavor with a good balance of sweetness and saltiness.
  • โ€ขOffers good spreadability and compares favorably to other brands.
  • โ€ขFirsime users found the experience highly positive, with a preference over long-term organic and conventional options.
  • โ€ขUnmatched taste makes it a great option for peanut butter lovers.

Cons

  • โ€ขSome users find the consistency more liquid due to excess oil, though refrigeration can help.
  • โ€ขConcerns about its sweetness not meeting expectations for a sugaree product.
  • โ€ขPotential allergen issues for sensitive users.
  • โ€ขShort shelf life with a 'best by' date 60 days from receipt, worrying some consumers.

Bottom Line

KIRKLAND Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is a top choice valued for its taste and use of quality Valencia peanuts. While its flavor and consistency impress, the shelf life might be a concern for some. For those prioritizing organic ingredients and superb taste, it's a highly recommended option. If you're looking for a less liquid consistency without refrigeration, consider checking alternatives out there.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$18.41 at Amazon
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

ยฉ 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..