Pros

  • Considered the best peanut butter available, with strong recommendations from repeat purchasers.
  • Made with Valencia peanuts, which are praised for superior taste.
  • Provides excellent value, especially for organic peanut butter.
  • Tasty flavor with a good balance of sweetness and saltiness.
  • Offers good spreadability and compares favorably to other brands.
  • Firsime users found the experience highly positive, with a preference over long-term organic and conventional options.
  • Unmatched taste makes it a great option for peanut butter lovers.

Cons

  • Some users find the consistency more liquid due to excess oil, though refrigeration can help.
  • Concerns about its sweetness not meeting expectations for a sugaree product.
  • Potential allergen issues for sensitive users.
  • Short shelf life with a 'best by' date 60 days from receipt, worrying some consumers.

Bottom Line

KIRKLAND Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is a top choice valued for its taste and use of quality Valencia peanuts. While its flavor and consistency impress, the shelf life might be a concern for some. For those prioritizing organic ingredients and superb taste, it's a highly recommended option. If you're looking for a less liquid consistency without refrigeration, consider checking alternatives out there.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$37.41 at Shop.com

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: May 25th 2025 3:44 am
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..