TLDR Review: Highland Lake Vinyl Plank Flooring
Verdict
If you want a stunning, waterproof luxury vinyl plank floor that installs easily and looks like the real deal, the *Home Decorators Collection Highland Lake* is a solid choice, especially if you’re doing the installation yourself. However, be prepared for a higher-than-average chance of damaged pieces on arrival and plan accordingly—this might mean ordering extra or being ready for some workaround with imperfect planks. If you want a similarly attractive and resilient option with possibly less shipping damage risk, it may be worth exploring other brands known for thicker packaging and better damage control. Overall, this product shines in appearance and ease of installation but leaves some room for improvement in shipping and quality control.
- Top pro:
- The flooring looks great with a lifelike appearance and slight color variations that add realism and style to any room.
- Top con:
- Approximately 25% of pieces can arrive damaged, which is higher than the industry standard of about 10% breakage — expect some extra effort dealing with imperfect pieces.
Pros
- •The flooring looks great with a lifelike appearance and slight color variations that add realism and style to any room.
- •Installation is very easy and quick, often completed in about half a day by one person, thanks to the waterproof click-lock design.
- •High-quality luxury vinyl plank that significantly enhances the home’s appearance, making it a popular choice for bedroom and other interior upgrades.
- •The product meets and even exceeds expectations for luxury vinyl flooring in terms of durability and aesthetic appeal.
- •Vendor support is helpful and responsive once contact is established, with replacement boxes sent quickly when needed.
- •This flooring is highly recommended by users, many planning to purchase more to cover additional rooms.
- •Installation is simpler and faster than peel-and-stick or traditional tile, reducing hassle and labor costs.
Cons
- •Approximately 25% of pieces can arrive damaged, which is higher than the industry standard of about 10% breakage — expect some extra effort dealing with imperfect pieces.
- •Damaged and mis-cut pieces can render parts of the shipment unusable, which is extremely frustrating and impacts overall project progress.
- •Packaging could be better, as insufficient cushioning often leads to more damage during shipping.
- •Some users report difficulty contacting the vendor initially, though issues are resolved more smoothly after public review posts.
- •Used or open-box items may have significant damage, especially at piece ends, requiring extra cutting and fitting that can be inconvenient.
- •The product’s packaging has been reported to sometimes appear tampered with or poorly resealed, raising concerns about product integrity on arrival.
- •Those needing larger coverage may find the 23.77 sq. ft. per case somewhat limiting, requiring multiple cases for full room installation.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
How we researched this
About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from 1 retailer in ShopSavvy's price data, most recently seen Sep 30, 2026.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
