TLDR Review: Goodyear Eagle Sport All Season Tire 235/45R18
Verdict
The GOODYEAR Eagle Sport All Season 235/45R18 94V generally delivers solid all-season performance, good longevity, and a quiet comfortable ride well-suited for sporty passenger cars, especially when nitrogen inflation is used for maintaining tire pressure and extending tire life. However, the concerning reports of early sidewall failures, inaccurate tire shipments (Eagle Sport 2 instead of Eagle Sport), and poor customer service response should not be ignored. If you drive regularly in snowy or icy conditions, you may want to look elsewhere since the tread is more summer-oriented and lacks traction sipes. If safety and reliable service are your top priorities, consider comparing this option with other reputable all-season tires known for better winter traction and stronger sidewall construction before purchasing.
- Top pro:
- Tires have demonstrated longevity, lasting over 60,000 miles in previous purchases, suggesting good durability.
- Top con:
- Several users report receiving Eagle Sport 2 tires instead of the advertised Eagle Sport, which have a summer tread unsuited for snow and ice, making them unsafe in true winter conditions.
Pros
- •Tires have demonstrated longevity, lasting over 60,000 miles in previous purchases, suggesting good durability.
- •Perform well across a range of conditions including wet weather, dry pavement, and light ice and snow.
- •Provide good handling that meets expectations for sporty cars with handling packages.
- •Nitrogen inflation is recommended, which users report improves fuel mileage by over 3 mpg and maintains stable tire pressure regardless of temperature fluctuations.
- •Tires offer a quiet and comfortable ride, enhancing the overall driving experience.
- •Installation is straightforward when done through a trusted installer, with proper attention to safety details like lug nut torque.
- •Excellent traction and grip in rainy conditions, contributing to safer driving.
- •The brand has a history of trustworthiness and consistency, encouraging multiple repeat purchases.
- •Tires give a safer, more reliable driving experience with increased driver confidence, especially on expressways.
Cons
- •Several users report receiving Eagle Sport 2 tires instead of the advertised Eagle Sport, which have a summer tread unsuited for snow and ice, making them unsafe in true winter conditions.
- •There are documented reports of dangerous sidewall separation occurring as early as three weeks after purchase, posing serious safety risks.
- •Sidewalls have been described as thinner compared to winter tires, leading to premature flats under normal driving conditions.
- •Customer service from both Goodyear and Walmart has been criticized for poor responsiveness and lack of follow-through on replacements or exchanges.
- •Tires experienced tread depth discrepancies, with some measuring under 8.5/32 instead of the claimed 10/32, raising concerns about product accuracy.
- •Installation for run flat or low profile tires (although not specifically indicated for this model) can be problematic through standard retailers like Walmart or Pep Boys, often requiring more expensive and time-consuming local shop visits.
- •Some customers report that dealer support for sidewall damage or early tire failure is limited or non-existent.
- •Replacement promises (no-charge) have often gone unfulfilled with long delays and no contact after initial claims.
- •Tires were removed from Walmart’s website due to reported issues, signaling a potential recall or widespread problem.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
How we researched this
About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
