TLDR Review: Good & Gather Creamy Peanut Butter

Published: May 28th, 2025
Last Updated: July 18th, 2025

Pros

  • β€’Exceptional taste and consistency, with some describing it as what peanut butter should be.
  • β€’Satisfied customers have committed to buying this brand repeatedly.
  • β€’Perfect for enhancing with chopped peanuts for additional texture.
  • β€’Creamy smooth texture that is easy to spread.
  • β€’Affordable and made with minimal ingredients.
  • β€’Considered a good JIF alternative, especially during the recall period.
  • β€’Recommended by some over other brands like Skippy and Peter Pan.

Cons

  • β€’Extremely viscous texture makes it difficult to spread and can ruin bread.
  • β€’Flavor perceived as mediocre and not enjoyable by some, described as salty and lacking overall taste.
  • β€’Thicker consistency compared to other peanut butters, which might not appeal to everyone.
  • β€’Some customers find the product different from initially loved batches, noting a recent recipe change.
  • β€’Efforts to mix it with jelly or Nutella fail to improve the flavor.

Bottom Line

Creamy Peanut Butter by Good & Gather presents a mixed bag of experiences. While some customers appreciate its creaminess and affordability, others criticize its thick texture and taste. If you prefer a smooth, creamy spread similar to JIF, this could be a choice, but if you're particular about flavor or consistency, you might want to sample a smaller size first or explore other options.

Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$1.99 at Target

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: August 6th 2025 3:27 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
πŸŽ₯
B

YABER T2 Plus Projector & Screen Kit

4 hours ago
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
πŸ’Ύ
B

15% Off WD_BLACK SN7100 NVMe SSDs!

3 days ago

Β© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..