Pros
- •Exceptional taste and consistency, with some describing it as what peanut butter should be.
- •Satisfied customers have committed to buying this brand repeatedly.
- •Perfect for enhancing with chopped peanuts for additional texture.
- •Creamy smooth texture that is easy to spread.
- •Affordable and made with minimal ingredients.
- •Considered a good JIF alternative, especially during the recall period.
- •Recommended by some over other brands like Skippy and Peter Pan.
Cons
- •Extremely viscous texture makes it difficult to spread and can ruin bread.
- •Flavor perceived as mediocre and not enjoyable by some, described as salty and lacking overall taste.
- •Thicker consistency compared to other peanut butters, which might not appeal to everyone.
- •Some customers find the product different from initially loved batches, noting a recent recipe change.
- •Efforts to mix it with jelly or Nutella fail to improve the flavor.
Bottom Line
Creamy Peanut Butter by Good & Gather presents a mixed bag of experiences. While some customers appreciate its creaminess and affordability, others criticize its thick texture and taste. If you prefer a smooth, creamy spread similar to JIF, this could be a choice, but if you're particular about flavor or consistency, you might want to sample a smaller size first or explore other options.
Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$1.99 at TargetWhere to Buy
Prices last updated: August 27th 2025 3:27 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!