Score

The e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm receives a moderate score due to its effective makeup removal and hydrating capabilities, making it a solid choice for many users. However, some have noted a struggle with removing stubborn mascara and post-use eye blurriness, highlighting variability in performance. At a budget-friendly price, it offers good value, though it may not surpass more expensive alternatives for every user.

6/10
Expert
7.9/10
Consumer

Pros

  • Effectively removes makeup without leaving residue.
  • Infused with hyaluronic acid, providing hydration to the skin.
  • Suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin.
  • Leaves skin feeling soft and moisturized.
  • Convenient and traveriendly packaging.
  • Pleasant, unscented formula that doesn't irritate the skin.
  • Affordable price point for the quality provided.

Cons

  • Some users felt it didn't fully remove waterproof makeup.
  • Texture can be too greasy for some preferences.
  • May not be sufficient for heavy or stage makeup removal.
  • Requires a second cleanse to remove all product residue.
  • A few users experienced breakouts or clogged pores after use.

Bottom Line

The e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm is a budget-friendly option that effectively removes makeup and provides hydration with its hyaluronic acid formula. It’s especially suitable for sensitive skin and comes in convenient packaging. However, it might not be as effective for removing waterproof makeup and could require additional cleansing steps. Overall, it offers great value for everyday makeup removal.

Product Score

Based on professional reviews and customer feedback

6.95/10
Overall
6/10
Expert
7.9
Consumer

Why this score?

The e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm receives a moderate score due to its effective makeup removal and hydrating capabilities, making it a solid choice for many users. However, some have noted a struggle with removing stubborn mascara and post-use eye blurriness, highlighting variability in performance. At a budget-friendly price, it offers good value, though it may not surpass more expensive alternatives for every user.

8+ Excellent
6-8 Good
4-6 Average
<4 Poor
Lowest at Amazon
$11.00 at Amazon
Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$10.00 at Bed Bath & Beyond
How we researched this

About this review: We pulled together findings from professional reviews and hundreds of user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from 33 retailers to give you the short version.

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: May 12th 2026 1:13 pm
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy AppDownload ShopSavvy App

Compare prices across thousands of stores in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.

Install ShopSavvy Browser ExtensionInstall ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

Latest Deals

🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

2 months ago
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️
🛍️

2 months ago