Verdict

The Cuisinart ICE-21P1 is a convenient choice for homemade soft-serve and frozen treats, offering quick churning and high-quality results. However, it requires planning for long freeze times and may need extra steps for firmer ice cream and easier removal. Ideal for those prioritizing ease of use and variety, but less suited if you want a machine that produces scoop-ready ice cream effortlessly.

Top pro:
Easy to assemble and clean, making homemade ice cream less of a chore
Top con:
Takes a long time to freeze the bowl, about 16-24 hours, requiring planning ahead
Get an alert when the price drops or it comes back in stock.

Pros

  • •Easy to assemble and clean, making homemade ice cream less of a chore
  • •Produces delicious, smooth-textured ice cream with a great overall quality
  • •Efficiently makes soft-serve ice cream in about 20-25 minutes, perfect for quick treats
  • •No need for rock salt and ice, simplifying the process
  • •Comes with BPA-free, high-quality parts and a 3-year limited warranty for peace of mind
  • •The freezer bowl eliminates the need for a compressor, reducing cost and potential breakdowns
  • •Easy to add ingredients during churning for customization
  • •Operates with a simple on-off switch, making it straightforward to use
  • •Safe for supervised use around children due to stationary paddle design
  • •Capable of making a variety of frozen treats like sorbet and frozen yogurt

Cons

  • •Takes a long time to freeze the bowl, about 16-24 hours, requiring planning ahead
  • •Not very effective at scooping out ice cream, leading to waste and some frustration
  • •Produces only soft-serve consistency; harder textures require extra freezing steps
  • •Can be noisy while running, especially as the mixture becomes solid
  • •Liquid sometimes freezes too quickly on the sides before the paddle can churn, causing waste
  • •Instructions can be unclear, leading to some trial and error during usage
  • •Churning may be challenging when the mixture thickens or sticks to the sides
  • •Removing the ice cream from the canister can be tricky and messy
  • •Some reviews mention that the freezing process can be inconsistent or slow, requiring patience
  • •The process of pouring ingredients is not well detailed, needing more clarification
Lowest at Amazon
$66.99 at Amazon
Price seen Jun 11, 2026

We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money

How we researched this

About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from 6 retailers in ShopSavvy's price data, most recently seen Jun 11, 2026.

Discussion

Know something we should add, or spot a detail that has changed? Tell us below. We check it against the maker's information and update the article.

Where to Buy

Prices last seen Apr 25, 2025 to Jun 11, 2026
RetailerPriceLast seenBuy
$59.99Apr 25, 2025
may have changed
$66.99Jun 11, 2026
may have changed
$69.95Apr 25, 2025
may have changed
$69.95Apr 25, 2025
may have changed
$69.95Apr 25, 2025
may have changed
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy AppDownload ShopSavvy App

Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.

Install ShopSavvy Browser ExtensionInstall ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

More Answers

If you're still curious about the Cuisinart ICE-21 Ice Cream Maker, here are some other answers you might find interesting: