Pros

  • Excellent for tightlining; stays on the upper water line effectively.
  • Truly waterproof; does not transfer to the lower lashline.
  • Once set, it does not budge or smear throughout the day.

Cons

  • Requires a waterproof makeup remover for effective removal.
  • Recommended removal method is timonsuming, requiring a soak and gentle wiping.

Bottom Line

The CoverGirl 230 Black Ink Ink It! Eye Pencil is an outstanding choice if you're looking for a long-lasting, waterproof eyeliner that excels at tightlining without smudging. However, be prepared to spend a little extra time on removal using a waterproof makeup remover. If you're seeking fuss-free precision and longevity, this pencil is definitely worth considering.

Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..