TLDR Review: American Standard Bath Drain
Pros
- •Specifically designed to fit a wide range of American Standard tubs, including larger models, ensuring compatibility.
- •Includes two waste tees to accommodate very large tubs.
- •Solid aletal construction offers better durability compared to generic plastic alternatives.
- •Overflow tube face is angled with a gasket to effectively prevent leaks.
- •The finish in satin nickel matches well and complements other bathroom trim with relatively high quality.
- •Works well with newly purchased tubs and performs its intended function adequately.
- •Generally reliable quality that meets basic expectations for daily use.
- •Setup is straightforward for those with plumbing experience, allowing for relatively quick installation once understood.
- •Offers good value in terms of features and performance consistency.
- •Customer support is reported to be responsive and helpful when contacted.
Cons
- •Cannot be retrofitted to existing tubs without access to the back wall, limiting replacement options.
- •Requires cutting overflow and drain pipes for proper fit, and some adjustment beyond instructions.
- •Drain stopper linkage is a major weak point, prone to breaking frequently (reported twice within 8 months).
- •Replacing the linkage is inconvenient because it requires removing the entire drain assembly.
- •Drain mechanism is not very smooth; the spring is weak and often needs manual help to operate fully.
- •Adjustment of the pop drain linkage is difficult and time-consuming, sometimes taking about an hour or more.
- •Instructions for adjustment are vague and unhelpful, even for experienced installers.
- •The knob’s shaft has two ings that bind over time, requiring regular lubrication.
- •The slotted brass set screw holding the handle is prone to stripping, complicating maintenance.
- •Hair accumulates more on the drain spring than expected, increasing the need for disassembly and cleaning.
- •The overall design quality appears flawed with multiple failure points causing repeated repair needs, sometimes requiring professional plumbers and extra costs.
- •The white paint finish (not satin nickel but related variants) deteriorates over time.
- •The brass screw used is soft, making disassembly difficult; replacing it with a stainless steel M6 screw is recommended.
Bottom Line
The American Standard 1583.470.295 Universal Bath Drain in satin nickel excels in fit and finish tailored for American Standard tubs, offering solid metal durability and leak prevention. However, the pop-up drain linkage design is a significant Achilles’ heel—expect frequent adjustments, potential breakage, and tricky repairs that can become a hassle and costly over time. If you value hassle-free maintenance and a smoother drain operation, you might want to consider alternatives with better linkage durability and easier serviceability. Nonetheless, if you're committed to American Standard tubs and prepared for some elbow grease, this drain will deliver the essential function with style.
Where to Buy
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!