🎹For a music student, the Hohner 32B is the melodica to start with: 32 keys covering two and a half octaves, a short mouthpiece and a flexible tube included, and one of the lowest prices of any name-brand model. Players who outgrow it usually move to a 37-key instrument such as the Yamaha P37D or the Suzuki M-37C.
How we chose. ShopSavvy doesn't play or test instruments. These picks come from the manufacturers' published specifications, Amazon owner ratings recorded by ShopSavvy (all five sit between 4.6 and 4.7 stars where we have them), and ShopSavvy's own price records. Our price data for melodicas is thin, 32 observations from 3 retailers between July 2022 and October 2024, so treat the prices below as a guide and check current listings.
What to look for. Key count sets the range: 32 keys is enough for most school and pop parts, 37 keys gives a full three octaves. Pricier models such as the Suzuki add phosphor bronze reeds and aluminum covers. Make sure both a short mouthpiece and a tube are included, since the tube lets you play with the keyboard flat on a table, which is how most beginners learn.
At a glance (prices ShopSavvy recorded):

The Hohner 32B is Hohner's student melodica: 32 piano-style keys from F to C (about two and a half octaves), which Hohner pitches as enough range for pop and rock parts and more than its 26-key model. It is light, easy to hold for long practice sessions, and the right size for a school music bag.
Its plastic build is fine for learning but not the last melodica a serious player buys; the 37-key models below have more range and sturdier construction.
Amazon owners rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 865 ratings recorded by ShopSavvy. In October 2024 Amazon listed it at $49.99, and the nine prices we recorded that month had a median of $55.99.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
Still curious about the Hohner 32B Melodica? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

The Yamaha P37D covers a full three octaves, F3 to F6, on 37 keys. Yamaha gives each key its own suspension spring and anti-vibration guides so keys press and release evenly, and a seamless rubber seal keeps air from leaking, which helps it sound full without much breath.
It is the natural next step from a 32-key student model for players who need the extra range, at roughly twice the price of the Hohner.
Amazon owners rate it 4.7 out of 5 across 598 ratings recorded by ShopSavvy. The nine prices we recorded in September 2024 had a median of $95.47.
Still curious about the Yamaha P37D Melodica? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

The Suzuki M-37C is an alto melodion with 37 keys, phosphor bronze reeds and aluminum covers, a build Suzuki aims at serious hobbyists and performers. It comes with three mouthpieces (standard, trumpet-style and a flexible tube) and a soft gig bag.
It costs the most here, and at about 3.5 pounds it is heavier than the plastic-bodied student models.
Amazon owners rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 598 ratings recorded by ShopSavvy. Every price we recorded for it, in September and October 2024, was $169.99.
Still curious about the Suzuki M-37C Melodica? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

The Eastar 32-key melodica is a soprano model sold with two soft long tubes, short mouthpieces and a carrying bag, at well under half the price of the Hohner. It is the most-rated melodica on this page, which says a lot of people have bought one as a first instrument or a spare.
Owner feedback on build quality is more mixed than on the Hohner or Yamaha, so it suits trying the instrument out more than years of daily practice.
Amazon owners rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 2,870 ratings recorded by ShopSavvy. We have two prices for it, $20.76 and $24.52, from September and October 2024.
Still curious about the Eastar 32 Keys Melodica? Here are some answers you might find interesting:

The Schoenhut Puff-n-Play has 25 keys, a smaller keyboard that suits small hands and a first introduction to playing by ear. Schoenhut is best known for toy pianos, and this is built for younger children rather than school band use.
Twenty-five keys is two octaves, so kids who start lessons will outgrow it; for a student old enough for music class, the Hohner 32B is the better buy.
ShopSavvy's price data for it is old: two prices from July 2022, $43.16 and $46.57. Check current listings before buying.
How we chose these: these picks weigh published manufacturer specifications and aggregated owner and expert reviews for the 5 products listed here, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data. No retailer or brand pays to be included.
Know something we should add, or spot a detail that has changed? Tell us below. We check it against the maker's information and update the article.
Download ShopSavvy AppCompare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser ExtensionCompare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.