Best Electric Toasters for 2024

The Breville BTA840XL Die-Cast 4-Slice Toaster stands out as our top pick for its outstanding design and performance. It features extra-wide slots that are perfect for bagels and artisanal bread. With intuitive controls and durable die-cast construction, this toaster ensures even and consistent toasting every time. The 'Lift & Look' feature lets you check your toast without interrupting the cycle, while the 'A Bit More' button allows for some extra toasting time if needed. According to our research, users love its reliable performance and sleek appearance.

The Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster is a great runner-up, offering excellent value and dependable performance. This toaster comes with dual control panels, enabling you to toast two different sets of items simultaneously with varied settings. Its combination of brushed stainless steel and black accents gives it a timeless look that fits well in any kitchen. Wide slots accommodate various bread types, and its versatile browning controls, along with a dedicated bagel setting, make it a popular choice among users.

Perfect for those on a budget, the Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster is a compact and affordable option that doesn’t compromise on performance. It sports a brushed stainless steel body with easy-to-use dial controls for adjusting toast shades from light to dark. Extra-wide slots can handle bagels, Texas Toast, and thick slices of bread. The toaster also features an auto-shutoff option and a cancel button to prevent over-toasting. According to our research, this model is especially favored by college students and those with limited kitchen space.

For larger families, the Breville Die-Cast BTA830XL toaster is a fantastic long-slot option packed with advanced features. An LED screen indicates the time left in the toasting cycle, and the 'Lift & Look' function lets you check your toast without stopping the process. The 'A Bit More' button adds extra toasting time, perfect for those who want precise control over their toast levels. Its defrost function handles denser breads like English muffins effortlessly, and the motorized lowering and lifting mechanism adds a touch of convenience and style.

If you love retro style, the Smeg Two-Slice '50s-Style Toaster brings the charm of yesteryears to your kitchen while delivering consistent performance. This model features two extra-wide slots and six toasting levels, making it suitable for various bread types. The iconic pop-up chrome lever adds both vintage charm and functional elegance. According to the manufacturer, this product is a great fit for those who have ample counter space and want to inject a bit of nostalgia into their daily routine.

Bagel enthusiasts will find the Hamilton Beach 24810 to be an ideal choice. Specifically designed to toast bagels perfectly every time, this toaster also features wide slots that accommodate different types of bread. Its compact size saves valuable counter space, and safety features like automatic shutoff offer peace of mind. The defrost and reheat options add versatility, making this toaster a valuable addition to any kitchen.