Wish-Bone Thousand Island Dressing
Where to Buy
| Retailer | Price | Last seen | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
F fleetfarm | $3.49 | Mar 13, 2026, may have changed | Buy Now |
 Walmart 90-day returns (in store too) | $4.32 | Nov 12, 2024, may have changed | Buy Now |
T treatspree | $6.99 | Mar 13, 2026, may have changed | Buy Now |
Prices are collected from retailer listings; each row shows the date we last saw that price. Return and shipping terms are each store's standard policy from our retailer research (April 2026). Some products and categories have different terms, so check with the store before you buy.
Pros
- •The product maintains a familiar brand name and packaging for Thousand Island lovers.
- •Slight calorie reduction compared to earlier versions, appealing to those watching intake.
- •Some users may appreciate the lighter, thinner texture for certain uses like salad drizzling.
- •The increased sweetness might appeal to consumers who prefer a less tangy dressing.
Cons
- •The recipe change resulted in a much thinner, runnier, and watery consistency disliked by many.
- •The original creamier texture with egg yolks is gone, leading to a slimy and unpleasant mouthfeel.
- •Taste is sharp, bitter, and sometimes described as disgusting with a burning sensation in the throat.
- •Reduced relish bits and tomato paste flavor make the dressing less flavorful and enjoyable.
- •The dressing now tastes more like a cheap, generic alternative, losing its distinctive charm.
- •Expiration date is only on the removable seal, complicating freshness checks.
- •Recipe changes have raised allergen concerns, with reports of allergic reactions reminiscent of eggs despite no egg listing.
- •The thinner dressing soaks into bread, making it unsuitable for spreads or dips.
- •Many longtime fans feel the product was "ruined" and no longer resembles the classic Thousand Island they preferred.
Bottom Line
If you loved the original Wish-Bone Thousand Island dressing, beware—the recipe change has disappointed a large portion of users with its thinner texture, bitter aftertaste, and overall decline in flavor quality. The dressing now runs watery and lacks the creamy, relish-rich character it once had. We recommend considering alternative Thousand Island dressings that retain a thicker texture and balanced flavor for a better experience, as this version seems to have sacrificed quality for a lighter formula. If you want to explore other options, we’d be happy to help you find a product that delivers the taste and texture you miss.
What Reviewers Are Saying
📚More About Wish-Bone Thousand Island Dressing
Discussion
ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are collected from retailer listings, and each one shows the date we last saw it. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.