Best Toasters for 2024

The Revolution InstaGlo R270 is our top pick for the best overall toaster in 2024. Distinguished by its supersonic toasting speed and a responsive touchscreen that's larger than an iPhone 13, this toaster offers convenience and precision. The innovative diamond-shaped heating element allows faster heating and reduced energy consumption compared to traditional coils. This model can toast over 34 types of bread with preprogrammed settings, including a specific gluten-free option. Although it lacks Wi-Fi capability, its focused functionalities and premium toasting performance make it worth the $399 investment.

The Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster is our runner-up, offering an ideal balance between design and functionality. It boasts a motorized lift and extra-wide slots that can handle various bread thicknesses with ease. Exclusive features like the 'A Bit More' setting allow for slight adjustments to achieve the perfect toast. Consistently delivering impeccable results, this model is priced at $200, making it a formidable contender among higher-priced toasters.

The BLACK+DECKER 2-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster is the go-to option for budget-conscious buyers. At just $25, it features a straightforward design and a removable crumb tray for easy cleaning. The extra-wide slots can accommodate thick slices of bread or bagels, ensuring precise and consistent toasting every time. It’s an excellent value choice that doesn’t skimp on quality.

The Ninja Foodi 2-in-1 Flip Toaster Oven is perfect for those with limited counter space. This versatile toaster functions both as an upright toaster and a toaster oven, reaching temperatures up to 400 degrees for various cooking needs. Its compact, adaptable design is ideal for small kitchens without sacrificing functionality. It's an intelligent choice for those looking to maximize their kitchen space.

For design-conscious consumers, the Smeg 2-Slice Toaster offers both aesthetic appeal and functionality. Known for its retro look and trendy color options, it brings a touch of vintage charm to any kitchen. Beyond its stylish exterior, this toaster excels in evenly toasting bagels and waffles. Priced at $200, it beautifully combines form and function.

The KitchenAid 4-Slice Toaster is the best choice for bagel enthusiasts. With extra-wide slots specifically designed to accommodate bagels, it toasts them evenly and to perfection. Priced at $79, it strikes an excellent balance between affordability and specialized performance tailored to bagel lovers.