Best Shuffleboard Pucks for 2026
🏆The right shuffleboard puck depends first on your table. GSE's listing puts it plainly: 2-1/8" pucks are for 9', 12' and 14' tables, and 2-5/16" pucks are for 16' to 22' tables. Get that right and almost any steel-bottomed set will play well; get it wrong and the best puck in the world will feel off.
For a full-size table, the GSE Games & Sports Expert set of 8 is the one to buy: hardened steel with plastic caps, offered in both diameters, rated 4.4 out of 5 across 118 Amazon ratings, and the most widely stocked set in ShopSavvy's records. For 9- to 14-foot home tables, the IdealEnjoy and YDDS 2-1/8" sets carry slightly higher owner ratings for less money, and TORPSPORTS' orange-and-black set was the cheapest we saw.
What to look for
Diameter. Match it to the table length above. Regulation-size 2-5/16" pucks on a 9-foot table crowd the scoring zones; small pucks on a 22-foot table feel light.
Weight and materials. Table pucks are weighted metal with a cap on top, which is why they are also sold as shuffleboard weights. GSE, IdealEnjoy and YDDS all list steel bodies; look for that spelled out in a listing rather than assumed.
Two colors, four each. A standard set is eight pucks, four per player color. Pick colors you can tell apart from the far end of the table.
Powder matters as much as pucks. Table speed comes from the shuffleboard powder. On Sun-Glo's scale, lower numbers are faster, and Speed 1 (Super Glide) is sold for 18- to 22-foot tables. ShopSavvy last saw a 16 oz can of Speed 1 at $17.18 and Speed 3 at $14.90 on Amazon on March 11, 2023.
How we chose
ShopSavvy doesn't test products. These picks come from the shuffleboard pucks in ShopSavvy's catalog, chosen on what each maker lists (diameter, materials, set size), on the Amazon owner ratings ShopSavvy last recorded for each, and on ShopSavvy's price records: 15 prices for these four sets between September 28 and October 5, 2024. Those prices are two years old, so check today's price before you buy.
At a glance
- GSE Games & Sports Expert set of 8 (best overall, both sizes): $77.82 at Amazon on October 5, 2024; median $81.58 across 10 prices at 7 stores
- IdealEnjoy 2-1/8" set of 8 (runner-up, 9' to 14' tables): $45.99 to $49.99 at Amazon on October 3, 2024
- YDDS indoor 2-1/8" set of 8 (9-foot tables): $45.99 at Amazon, September 29 and October 3, 2024
- TORPSPORTS 2-1/8" set of 8 (budget): $40.99 at Amazon on October 5, 2024
🥇Overall Best: Shuffleboard Pucks Set
GSE's set is the safest choice because it comes in both sizes: 2-1/8" for 9- to 14-foot tables and 2-5/16" for 16- to 22-foot tables, according to GSE's listing. Each puck is hardened steel with a plastic cap, and the set is eight pucks, four of each cap color (chrome and bronze in the version tracked here).
Owners rate it 4.4 out of 5 across 118 Amazon ratings, with 67% five-star, as last recorded by ShopSavvy. It is also the most widely stocked set in ShopSavvy's records: 10 prices at 7 stores between September 28 and October 5, 2024, from $77.82 at Amazon to $141.17 at Home Depot, a spread worth knowing before you buy.
It costs more than the generic 2-1/8" sets below, so on a small table those are the better value.
Bottom line: the set to buy for a full-length table, and a solid one for any table size.
We may earn a commission when you buy through these links, at no extra cost to you. How ShopSavvy makes money
📚More About Shuffleboard Pucks Set
More Answers
Still curious about the Shuffleboard Pucks Set? Here are some answers you might find interesting:
🥈Runner-up: Shuffleboard Pucks Set of 8
For 9- to 14-foot tables, IdealEnjoy's 2-1/8" (53 mm) set gives you most of what the GSE set does for a lot less. It is eight stainless-steel pucks in red and blue with beveled edges, and it carries the stronger owner rating of the two: 4.5 out of 5 across 102 Amazon ratings, 77% of them five-star, as last recorded by ShopSavvy.
Owner reviews summarized on its product page praise the balance and the grip of the beveled edge. The one caveat they raise is size: depending on the table, some owners find 53 mm too small or too large, so match the puck to your table length.
ShopSavvy saw it at $45.99 and $49.99 on Amazon on October 3, 2024.
Bottom line: the value pick for a home table up to 14 feet.
Best for 9-Foot Tables: Indoor Shuffleboard Pucks (Set of 8)
YDDS sells this 2-1/8" set as replacement pucks with stainless-steel bottoms and beveled tops, four of each of two colors, with several color pairs to match your table.
It has the highest owner rating of the four: 4.6 out of 5 across 79 Amazon ratings, 81% five-star, as last recorded by ShopSavvy. Owner reviews summarized on its product page single it out for 9-foot tables, and the main caveat they raise is the same as any 53 mm puck: it is smaller than regulation for long professional tables.
ShopSavvy saw it at $45.99 on Amazon on September 29 and October 3, 2024.
Bottom line: the pick for a compact 9-foot game-room table.
💸Budget Pick: Mini Shuffleboard Pucks (Orange & Black)
TORPSPORTS' orange-and-black set was the cheapest 2-1/8" set in ShopSavvy's records, at $40.99 on Amazon on October 5, 2024. It is the same 53 mm size as the two sets above, so it suits 9- to 14-foot tables.
Owners rate it 4.6 out of 5 across 112 Amazon ratings, 81% five-star, as last recorded by ShopSavvy. Owner reviews summarized on its product page mention the build quality and that each puck arrives individually bubble-wrapped. The bright colors are easy to tell apart from the far end of a table.
TORPSPORTS lists less detail about materials than YDDS or GSE do, so if you want a specified steel grade, pick one of those.
Bottom line: the least expensive way to replace a lost or mismatched home set.
📚More About Mini Shuffleboard Pucks (Orange & Black)
More Answers
Still curious about the Mini Shuffleboard Pucks (Orange & Black)? Here are some answers you might find interesting:
How we researched this
How we chose these: these picks weigh published manufacturer specifications and aggregated owner and expert reviews for the 4 products listed here, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data. No retailer or brand pays to be included.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across tens of thousands of stores, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
