Best Paella Pans for 2024

Our top pick for 2024, the Garcima 16-Inch Pata Negra Double Gauge Steel Paella Pan, stands out for its high-quality carbon steel construction, which heats evenly and is compatible with all stovetops, including electric, gas, and even charcoal grills. The sloped sides are designed to keep your ingredients contained while stirring, and the robust build ensures this pan will be a kitchen staple for years to come. Perfect for achieving that coveted socarrat, this versatile pan excels under various cooking conditions, making it the obvious choice for serious paella enthusiasts.

If you're looking for something slightly smaller but still want exceptional construction, the Mauviel M'Steel 14.2-Inch Paella Pan is a fantastic runner-up. Made from carbon steel, this pan provides excellent heat distribution and is well-known for consistently creating a perfect socarrat. With its stylish design, it doubles as an excellent option for other culinary endeavors, from shakshuka to baked dishes. Built to last, this pan is a worthwhile investment for dedicated home cooks.

For those on a budget, the Garcima 13-Inch Carbon Steel Paella Pan offers excellent performance without breaking the bank. This lighter, more compact option still provides the responsive heating that carbon steel is famous for. It's perfect for smaller households or beginner paella chefs. Despite its affordable price, it doesn’t compromise on quality, making it a great entry-level choice for those starting their paella-making journey.

The Machika 20-Inch Polished Steel Paella Pan is the go-to pick for those who prefer enameled steel. This material is low-maintenance—no seasoning required and resistant to rust. The pan heats evenly and quickly, ensuring your paella comes out flawlessly every time. Additionally, it's easy to clean, making it perfect for those who want top-tier performance with minimal upkeep. With this pan, you can enjoy the process and results of paella-making without the hassle.

For those who prefer a nonstick option, the Cuisinart Non-Stick 15-Inch Covered Paella Pan offers top-notch performance and hassle-free cleanup. With a spacious 15-inch diameter and flared sides, it enhances the even evaporation of liquids. The nonstick surface guarantees a beautiful crust without the rice sticking, and the large handles make it easy to maneuver. The included cover adds to its convenience, making it an excellent addition to any kitchen.