Best Canned Tomatoes for 2024

Bianco DiNapoli Organic Whole Peeled Tomatoes earn our top pick for their impeccable balance of sweetness and acidity, coupled with a robust tomato flavor. Packed in a thick puree, these tomatoes offer a semi-firm texture that creates an indulgent, velvety sauce perfect for numerous preparations. Whether you’re making a classic marinara or an international dish, these tomatoes are versatile enough to elevate your cooking.

Our runner-up, Cento San Marzano Tomatoes, stand out with their unique sweetness and rich flavor, attributed to the volcanic soils of Italy where they are cultivated. These tomatoes bring a nuanced depth to sauces, stews, and any recipe requiring a hearty tomato base. Their versatile nature makes them a staple in any kitchen.

Red Gold Tomatoes are our top budget pick, offering a surprisingly robust flavor without breaking the bank. These tomatoes maintain their integrity well during cooking, making them an excellent choice for those looking to save while still enjoying high-quality ingredients. Ideal for everyday recipes, they deliver consistent performance at an affordable price.

When it comes to homemade tomato sauce, Muir Glen Organic Tomatoes are the best choice. Known for their rich, natural sweetness and lovely texture, these organic tomatoes are also packed in BPA-free cans, aligning with health-conscious choices. Their exceptional flavor profile makes them a standout for any sauce recipe.

For recipes that thrive on chunky tomatoes, Del Monte Diced Tomatoes are an excellent pick. These tomatoes offer a well-balanced flavor free of any metallic aftertaste and retain their shape admirably in dishes like stews, chilis, and casseroles. They are the perfect ingredient when you need hearty tomato pieces that stand up to cooking.