
Macy's offers a solid 30-day return policy with free shipping, a generous 4-tier Star Rewards loyalty program, and price matching against a broad competitor list with a 10-day post-purchase adjustment. The big weakness is pricing transparency — Macy's has been repeatedly sued and settled over inflated 'regular' reference prices and phantom markdowns. Trust ratings on Trustpilot and Sitejabber are weak, though app store ratings are excellent.
Standard 30-day return window. Many categories have shorter windows: small electrics/personal care (10 days), tech/electronics (14 days with original packaging), designer handbags/premium brands (14 days). Free return shipping via prepaid label for most online orders, in-store returns at any Macy's location.
Macy's Price Match Policy matches prices at the time of purchase and up to 10 days after on in-stock identical items from a defined list of qualifying competitors. Does not match Macy's Backstage or Marketplace sellers.
Free standard shipping on orders $25+. Same-day delivery available in select metros for an additional fee (free for Platinum Star Rewards members on qualifying orders). Free in-store and curbside pickup at most Macy's locations. Ships internationally to 100+ countries via Borderfree/Global-e.
Star Rewards is free to join. The 4-tier structure rewards cardmembers more heavily; non-cardmembers stay at Bronze. Star Money is redeemable in $10 increments on future purchases.
Macy's is a frequent subject of deceptive-pricing lawsuits. In 2014, California AG's office sued Macy's over inflated 'regular prices.' The Los Angeles County DA settled with Macy's in 2019 for $1.5M over 'phantom markdown' / inflated reference pricing. Multiple ongoing class actions cite Macy's 'was/now' strike-through prices as reference prices items were rarely or never actually sold at.
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!