1-800-PetMeds logo
Retailer Report Card

1-800-PetMeds

1-800-PetMeds is a long-running NABP-accredited online pet pharmacy with a generous 90-day non-prescription return window, a free recurring rewards program, an A+ BBB rating (accredited since 2007), and a 4.1/5 Trustpilot score across 573 reviews. Its biggest weakness is pricing transparency: a 2025 class-action lawsuit alleges the strikethrough/'sale' prices on the site have been 'a total fiction' since 2009 — discounts on all products, all the time — which drags the overall grade down despite otherwise solid policies.

C+
Overall Grade
Researched 5/9/2026
Return window
90 days
Price matching
Yes
Free shipping
$49+
Trustpilot
4.1 / 5
BBB rating
A+
Loyalty program
PetMeds Rewards

Return Policy

A-
Return window
90 days
Holiday extension
No
Return shipping
Customer pays return shipping unless the return is due to a PetMeds error (incorrect or damaged item), in which case PetMeds covers the cost.
In-store returns
No
Receipt required
No
Final-sale categories
Prescription medications, Vaccines, Refrigerated items, Compound medications, Drop-shipped items

Non-prescription items: full refund within 90 days of receipt. Prescription medications: prorated refund may be offered up to 30 days after shipping. Damaged/incorrect items must be reported within 72 hours of delivery.

Price Matching

C-
Offers price matching
Yes
Competitors matched
Any NABP-accredited online pet pharmacy in the United States
Exclusions
Non-NABP-accredited pharmacies, Non-US pharmacies, Products not FDA/EPA approved for US sale, Non-identical products, Price-matched items are not eligible for additional special offers
How to request
Place your order, then contact customer service (1-800-738-6337 / customerservice@1800petmeds.com / fax 1-800-380-9555) with the competitor's pricing information. Total price (including shipping/handling) is what's compared.

Match is restricted to a single class of competitors (NABP-accredited US online pharmacies), not arbitrary retailers like Amazon, Walmart, or Chewy.

Shipping

B
Free shipping threshold
$49
Standard delivery
3–5 days
Same-day delivery
No
Store pickup
No
International shipping
No

Standard shipping FREE on orders over $49 (excludes refrigerated items), $6.99 below threshold. Priority (2-4 days): $8.99 over $49, $19.99 under. Overnight: flat $24.99. Orders after 3pm EST ship the next day; prescriptions need 1-2 extra days for vet approval.

Payment Methods

Apple Pay (online)
Yes
Apple Pay (in-store)
No
Google Pay
Yes
PayPal
Yes
Buy Now, Pay Later
Sezzle, Zip
Store credit card
No
Gift cards
No

Loyalty Program

A-
Program name
PetMeds Rewards
Free to join
Yes
Earning rate
1 point per $1 spent; 250 points = $5 loyalty credit (effective ~2% back). Points expire 1 year after the 250-point threshold is reached.
Tier benefits
Automatic enrollment for all shoppers, $5 loyalty credit at every 250-point threshold, AutoShip 5% recurring discount (often combined with promotional offers up to 35% off first order), Free vet video consults while enrolled in AutoShip

Single-tier program; AutoShip discount stacks with rewards program.

Customer Service

Live chat
Available during customer-care hours (Mon-Fri 8am-7pm ET, Sat 9am-5:30pm ET, closed Sundays)
Phone support
1-800-738-6337, Mon-Fri 8am-7pm ET, Sat 9am-5:30pm ET, closed Sundays
Email support
Yes
Avg. response time
No published SLA; site notes 'Due to unusually high call volumes, we are experiencing longer wait times.' Trustpilot reports the company replies to ~87% of negative reviews within 48 hours.

Pricing Transparency

D
Fake sales frequency
high
Strikethrough honesty
inflated
Dynamic pricing used
No

PetMeds is the subject of an active class-action lawsuit (Bird v. PetMed Express, N.D.N.Y., 2025) alleging that 'from 2009 to June 2024, PetMeds offered discounts on all of its products, all of the time' and that crossed-out 'regular' prices are 'a total fiction' that the company never actually charged for sustained periods, in alleged violation of federal false-reference-pricing rules.

Privacy & Data Practices

Sells customer data
No
Targeted advertising
Yes
Account required to shop
No

Third-Party Trust Ratings

Trustpilot
4.1 / 5 (573 reviews)
Better Business Bureau
A+ · Accredited
Sitejabber
1.9 / 5
Knoji
4.3 / 5
Apple App Store
4.9 / 5
Google Play
3.0 / 5

Company

Legal name
PetMed Express, Inc.
Headquarters
Delray Beach, Florida, USA
Founded
1996
Ticker
NASDAQ: PETS
Annual revenue
$0.2B
Employees
212

ShopSavvy Price Data

Products tracked
3,781
Price drops (last 12 months)
0
Real sale events / year
0

Sources