
1-800-PetMeds is a long-running NABP-accredited online pet pharmacy with a generous 90-day non-prescription return window, a free recurring rewards program, an A+ BBB rating (accredited since 2007), and a 4.1/5 Trustpilot score across 573 reviews. Its biggest weakness is pricing transparency: a 2025 class-action lawsuit alleges the strikethrough/'sale' prices on the site have been 'a total fiction' since 2009 — discounts on all products, all the time — which drags the overall grade down despite otherwise solid policies.
Non-prescription items: full refund within 90 days of receipt. Prescription medications: prorated refund may be offered up to 30 days after shipping. Damaged/incorrect items must be reported within 72 hours of delivery.
Match is restricted to a single class of competitors (NABP-accredited US online pharmacies), not arbitrary retailers like Amazon, Walmart, or Chewy.
Standard shipping FREE on orders over $49 (excludes refrigerated items), $6.99 below threshold. Priority (2-4 days): $8.99 over $49, $19.99 under. Overnight: flat $24.99. Orders after 3pm EST ship the next day; prescriptions need 1-2 extra days for vet approval.
Single-tier program; AutoShip discount stacks with rewards program.
PetMeds is the subject of an active class-action lawsuit (Bird v. PetMed Express, N.D.N.Y., 2025) alleging that 'from 2009 to June 2024, PetMeds offered discounts on all of its products, all of the time' and that crossed-out 'regular' prices are 'a total fiction' that the company never actually charged for sustained periods, in alleged violation of federal false-reference-pricing rules.
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!