Image 1 of 8
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 1
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 2
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 3
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 4
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 5
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 6
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 7
Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets - Image 8
Reynolds

Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets

$3.88across 8 retailers
Model: 10010900713358Color: WhiteUPC: 10900200707Free UPC lookup
Lowest price
$15.52 at Amazon
Price seen May 19, 2025

Where to Buy

Newest price seen: May 19, 2025
RetailerPriceLast seenBuy
B
brandclub.com
$3.88May 19, 2025, may have changedBuy Now
Amazon logo
Amazon
30-day returns (in store too)
$15.52May 19, 2025, may have changedBuy Now
Walmart logo
Walmart
90-day returns (in store too)
$18.15May 19, 2025, may have changedBuy Now
H
Homecery.com
$19.30May 19, 2025, may have changedBuy Now
F
foofster
$21.95May 19, 2025, may have changedBuy Now

Prices are collected from retailer listings; each row shows the date we last saw that price. Return and shipping terms are each store's standard policy from our retailer research (April 2026). Some products and categories have different terms, so check with the store before you buy.

Pros

  • •Convenient pre-cut parchment sheets eliminate the frustration of curling rolls.
  • •Perfectly sized for standard cookie sheets, aiding in easy and efficient baking.
  • •Versatile enough for cookies, biscuits, frozen yeast rolls, meatloaf, and more.
  • •Can be reused multiple times if not too soiled, enhancing value.
  • •High-quality paper that doesn’t scorch easily, though some discoloration may occur.
  • •Lack of 'waxy/shiny film' makes it preferable over some off-brand options.
  • •Storage box is more space-efficient compared to traditional rolls.
  • •Many consider it a kitchen essential, especially for frequent bakers.
  • •Its grid markings help with measuring, similar to rolled parchment.

Cons

  • •Slightly more expensive than traditional rolled parchment paper.
  • •Slightly shorter than standard cookie sheets, though still functional.
  • •Some users would prefer larger package options for convenience.
  • •Discoloration can occur at higher temperatures.

Bottom Line

Reynolds Cookie Baking Sheets deliver the convenience of pre-cut, high-quality parchment that many bakers appreciate. They're well-suited for a variety of baking needs and daily kitchen tasks. Although they come at a higher price tag compared to rolled options, the ease of use and reliability make them a valuable purchase for frequent bakers and professional chefs alike. Perfect for those who wish to skip the hassle of cutting parchment paper, while maintaining consistent baking results.

Read full expert review

What Reviewers Are Saying

Praised
pre cut parchment sheets20%
easy clean up30%
fits baking sheets20%
used multiple times20%
high quality paper10%
definitely recommend10%

Discussion

🔍About This Page

ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are collected from retailer listings, and each one shows the date we last saw it. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.

🔥 Trending Deals