REESE'S Creamy Peanut Butter
Where to Buy
| Retailer | Price | Last seen | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 Instacart | $3.38 | Jun 28, 2024, may have changed | Buy Now |
G Giant Food | $3.69 | May 10, 2023, may have changed | Buy Now |
P Publix Delivery | $3.87 | Jul 11, 2022, may have changed | Buy Now |
P Publix Delivery | $3.87 | Apr 27, 2023, may have changed | Buy Now |
U Uber Eats | $4.05 | Jun 28, 2024, may have changed | Buy Now |
Prices are collected from retailer listings; each row shows the date we last saw that price. Return and shipping terms are each store's standard policy from our retailer research (April 2026). Some products and categories have different terms, so check with the store before you buy.
Pros
- •Tastes like plain, regular peanut butter without any added sweetness or artificial flavor
- •Offers good value for the price, making it a budget-friendly choice
- •Has a pleasant, typical peanut butter flavor that satisfies basic expectations
- •Suitable for those who prefer a non-sweet, straightforward peanut spread
- •Performs satisfactorily for everyday use and functions well as a versatile ingredient
- •Kosher-certified, fitting dietary preferences
- •Comes in a large quantity (pack of 6), when correctly listed, providing long-term supply
- •Alternative to more expensive brands with similar flavor profiles
- •Tastes comparable to standard store-brand peanut butter, which some find reliable
- •Acceptable quality given its affordability
Cons
- •Does not taste like Reese’s cups or have any of the expected candy-like flavor; instead, it tastes just like regular peanut butter
- •Many reviews mention it’s bland or lacking the distinctive Reese’s flavor, leading to disappointment for those expecting a candy-inspired taste
- •Some users find it very similar to generic store brands, offering no unique features
- •Confusing product listing: mentions a pack of 6 but reviewers note only one jar was received or the listing is unclear
- •Not suitable if you're expecting a sweeter or candy-like peanut butter experience
- •Several reviews state the flavor has changed from earlier versions, becoming less sweet and more bland over time
- •Tastes nothing like the rich, creamy filling inside Reese’s cups, which may not meet candy lovers’ expectations
- •Not the highest quality, with some describing it as just okay for its price point
- •The flavor profile may have shifted from previous versions, potentially less appealing to long-time fans
- •Limited positive reviews focus on flavor; many critiques highlight the lack of the candy taste
Bottom Line
This peanut butter is a solid choice if you’re after a *plain, budget-friendly* spread without any surprises, but if you're craving that signature Reese’s candy flavor, this product falls flat. Many users find it bland and similar to store-brand options, so for matchless flavor, you might want to consider other options like Jif Creamy Peanut Butter or Peter Pan Creamy Honey Roast, which are known for a richer, sweeter taste. If simplicity and cost-efficiency are your priorities, this could serve you well, just don’t expect the iconic Reese’s flavor to shine through.
What Reviewers Are Saying
📚More About REESE'S Creamy Peanut Butter
Discussion
ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are collected from retailer listings, and each one shows the date we last saw it. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.