Image 1 of 3
Peter Pan
Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz
$5.24$60.00across 7 retailers
Model: Creamy Peanut ButterUPC: 45300000602
Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$7.59 at InstacartWhere to Buy
Prices last updated: May 1st 2026 3:35 pm
Pros
- •Flavorful and delicious, often described as transforming the peanut butter experience with a nostalgic, magical quality.
- •Smooth and creamy texture that many find enjoyable.
- •No added sugar and no hydrogenated oils, making it a cleaner option compared to some other brands.
- •Brings childhood joy and excitement to sandwiches, making it more than just a spread.
- •Contains all the classic peanut flavor expected from a creamy peanut butter.
Cons
- •Requires mixing due to oil separation, which can be messy and timonsuming, with some users experiencing liquid consistency after stirring.
- •Presence of hard bits in the jar, which can be unpleasant and potentially damage teeth.
- •Texture and taste are sometimes described as poorly made or off compared to higher quality brands.
- •Oil tends to accumulate heavily at the top, sometimes spilling out suddenly when opened, causing extra cleanup.
- •Color and flavor have changed for some users, with reports of an unpleasant taste likened to oil or wood shavings.
- •Overall quality concerns, including disappointment in packaging and suspected ingredient changes possibly due to cost cutting.
- •Several users note that repeated purchases result in inconsistent quality, prompting them to consider other brands.
Bottom Line
Peter Pan Gluten Free Creamy Peanut Butter offers a classic, nostalgic peanut butter flavor with a creamy texture that many love, but it comes with a few catches. The need to mix due to oil separation and occasional hard bits can be a dealbreaker if you prefer a perfectly smooth and consistent spread. Quality concerns and changes in taste noted by some longtime users suggest it might not satisfy peanut butter purists. If you want a hassle-free, consistently smooth experience without the mess of oil separation or texture issues, exploring other gluten-free peanut butter brands available at your grocery store may be a better option.
What Reviewers Are Saying
Praised
great taste11%
Criticized
color isn't right6%
tastes off17%
too oily22%
hard bits6%
messy to stir6%
not packaged well11%
📚More About Peter Pan Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz
Discussion
🔍About This Page
ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are updated regularly and verified for accuracy. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.
More to Explore
🔥 Trending Deals
Loading trending deals...
Footer 1
Get ShopSavvy
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!