TLDR Review: New York City Pumpernickel Bagels
Pros
- •Authentic New York Cittyle pumpernickel bagels with a strong, delicious flavor that many find irresistible.
- •Freshly baked taste and delightful aroma immediately noticeable upon opening the package.
- •Freezes and reheats exceptionally well, maintaining flavor and texture even after microwaving from frozen.
- •Largized bagels that will last a while, making a dozen a convenient quantity for regular enjoyment.
- •The bagels are generally welade with good texture and almost rival traditional pumpernickel from popular local bakeries.
Cons
- •Quality consistency is a major issue; multiple customers reported mold present right out of the box, making the entire package unusable.
- •Short shelf life — bagels need to be frozen immediately to prevent quick spoilage and molding.
- •Packaging is inadequate, with the product often arriving in an unsealed box inside a mailer, contributing to freshness problems.
- •Actual bagels tend to be a medium brown color, not the rich dark pumpernickel shown in images, which may disappoint those expecting classic pumpernickel appearance.
- •Delivery delays and issues increase the risk of receiving spoiled or unusable bagels.
- •The large size may be challenging to finish in one sitting, which can be a con if you prefer smaller portions.
Bottom Line
These 12 Fresh New York City Bagels (Pumpernickel) offer an authentic taste experience and great flavor for those who prioritize freshness and can manage freezing immediately upon arrival. However, the inconsistent quality and high risk of mold in some shipments make this product a gamble. If you want guaranteed freshness with less hassle, you might want to look for local bakeries or other trusted brands with better packaging and reliability. If you’re set on these, make sure to freeze them immediately and enjoy reheated bagels that still hold their delicious texture!
How we researched this
About this review: We pulled together findings from professional reviews and hundreds of user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices across thousands of stores in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more.
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!