Pros

  • Exceptionally thick, heaveight material provides superior warmth, making it perfect for very cold weather without needing an additional jacket.
  • True to size for many users, fitting comfortably without being snug or baggy, allowing full range of motion.
  • Oversized hood offers excellent wind protection and enough room to wear over hats or helmets, which is great for outdoor activities or work.
  • Henley button neck and snap placket design add ventilation options and extra comfort.
  • Rugged, durable construction built to withstand active, outdoor lifestyles, including demanding tasks like chainsaw work.
  • Rich, appealing black color and impressive overall craftsmanship make this sweatshirt stand out from typical outdoor or athletic wear.
  • Many users felt it was a good value given the quality and durability offered.
  • The snap neck collar adds to wind resistance and protection in cold, blustery conditions.
  • Excellent insulation performance around 30°F, keeping wearers warm and comfortable.
  • Quality is consistent with other Arborwear products known for reliability and toughness.

Cons

  • Sizing can run smaller than expected, especially in the body, arms, and shoulders; many recommend sizing up by one or even two sizes to get the right fit.
  • For those who size up to XXL or larger, the sweatshirt can end up feeling too long, especially in the torso.
  • The hood, while offering great coverage, can feel overly large or bulky when worn up.
  • Its heavy and sturdy nature means it’s not a lightweight layering option and may feel cumbersome for some casual uses.
  • Some users found the fit tight despite ordering larger sizes, suggesting fit variability depending on body type.

Bottom Line

The Arborwear Men's Double Thick Pullover Sweatshirt in Black is a heavyweight, beast of a sweatshirt engineered for cold, rugged outdoor use. It excels at providing warmth and wind resistance with premium construction and practical features like an oversized hood and snap neck collar. However, sizing issues mean you should strongly consider sizing up—possibly even twice—to get a comfortable fit, especially if you have broader shoulders or taller stature. If you want uncompromising warmth and durability for cold conditions and don’t mind a hefty sweatshirt, this is a solid choice. For a lighter or more traditionally fitted hoodie option, you may want to compare other outdoor brands, but for heavy-duty performance, this is one of the best out there.

Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

© 2025 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..