TLDR Review: Lou Malnati's Deep Dish Pizzas
Pros
- •Delivers an authentic Chicago deep dish pizza flavor that fans rave about.
- •Generous topping distribution, particularly the sausage and pepperoni.
- •Sauce is flavorful and placed on top, true to Chicago style tradition.
- •The cheese and pepperoni combo offers plenty of gooey, satisfying cheese.
- •Comes with four slices per pizza, perfect for sharing or multiple meals.
- •Convenient frozen option to keep on hand for a quick, enjoyable treat.
- •Over 20 years of consistently high quality noted by many repeat buyers.
- •Packaging uses dry ice to keep the pizzas fresh and properly chilled on arrival.
- •The crust, though harder than some expected, remains enjoyable and tasty when properly reheated.
- •Makes a unique and appreciated gift, especially for Chicago pizza lovers far away.
Cons
- •The crust is firmer and less light/crispy than some expect from Chicago deep dish.
- •Pizzas are smaller than anticipated, closer to personal pan size despite "deep dish" label.
- •Some reviewers found the taste disappointing compared to fresh or even other frozen pizzas.
- •Cooking from frozen can be tricky; thawing or adjusting bake times is often needed for best texture.
- •The saucn-top style and thinner crust may not satisfy traditionalists wanting a heavier, buttery crust.
- •A few users felt the overall quality and flavor didn’t measure up to their expectations.
Bottom Line
If you're craving an authentic Chicago deep dish experience at home with classic sausage and pepperoni flavors, Lou Malnati’s Two Deep Dish Pizzas deliver the right vibe and convenience, especially as a frozen option. Just know these pizzas lean toward a firmer crust and smaller size than you might expect from traditional Chicago deep dish, so temper your expectations accordingly. They shine as a gift or a comforting, quick indulgence rather than an exact replica of a fresh-from-the-pizzeria pie. If you prefer a lighter crust or bigger portions, you might want to explore other frozen pizza brands or local options, but for true Lou Malnati’s fans, this frozen pack is a solid choice.
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!