Pros

  • Made from 90% cotton and 10% lycra, these leggings are breathable, cool, and comfortable compared to synthetic options.
  • Provide good coverage that’s appropriate for public wear, unlike some leggings that feel like sheer pantyhose.
  • True to size with a consistent fit that suits various body types well, especially noted for XXL fitting well on taller, heavier frames.
  • Soft, warm fabric enhances alay comfort and works great for lounging or sleepwear.
  • Durable and welade, with many users reporting their pairs lasting up to two years despite frequent washing.
  • Stretchy without squeezing the waist or midsection, offering a noestrictive, stay-up fit.
  • Easy to care for with machine wash and dry, showing minimal color fading when washed inside out on low heat.
  • Versatile for wearing at home, layering under other clothing, running errands, or casual outings.
  • Thick enough for colder seasons and provides good coverage without being sehrough.
  • Classic and reliable brand known for quality basics and consistent performance.

Cons

  • Fabric can be thin and very sehrough in some cases, making it unsuitable for outdoor or public use for certain wearers.
  • Calf area fits extremely tight, causing discomfort or a “strangling” sensation, especially for those with average or larger calves. This tightness can also make the leggings slip down, requiring waistband adjustments.
  • Material can stretch out and become loose by the end of the day, which may affect fit but not necessarily comfort.
  • Some users find the leggings unflattering, producing a lumpy silhouette despite being slender.
  • Waistband is narrow, which might bother some when sitting, although it generally remains comfortable.
  • Not stretchy or supportive enough for exercise or higovement activities.
  • Lack of pockets might be inconvenient for those wanting functional leggings.

Bottom Line

These Hanes Women’s Stretch Jersey Leggings in Charcoal Heather are a *solid choice* if you want breathable, comfortable everyday leggings made from mostly cotton with a little stretch. They work beautifully for lounging, layering, and casual wear—especially if you appreciate longevity and softness. However, if you need something opaque and polished for activewear or you have muscular calves, beware of tightness and see-through fabric concerns. For a more athletic fit or leggings specifically designed for workouts, you might want to explore other brands tailored to that use. Overall, these leggings deliver excellent cozy comfort at a great price for casual wear.

Get ShopSavvy
ShopSavvy is totally free and works on all popular phones and browsers
Download ShopSavvy App

Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more

Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension

Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.

© 2026 Monolith Technologies, Inc. All rights reserved..