TLDR Review: Beef New York Strip Steak
Pros
- •The steak is fresh, welarbled, and delivers a juicy, tender, and flavorful eating experience.
- •It cooks evenly with a nice sear while maintaining its shape without excessive shrinking.
- •The natural beefy flavor is robust and only needs simple seasoning like salt and pepper.
- •Texture achieves a good balance—tender without being too soft.
- •Consistent quality with welrimmed portions and outstanding freshness.
- •Preparation tips, like using a weleated cast iron pan with butter or oil and letting the steak rest after cooking, enhance its flavor and tenderness.
- •Grased and pasture-raised, indicating a higher-quality, ethically sourced product.
- •Portion size is convenient for small meals or smaller households.
- •Cooking with methods like oven finishing and butter works well and brings out great flavor.
- •Many reviewers found it exceeded typical grocery store meat quality and were likely to purchase again.
Cons
- •Some steaks show slight inconsistency in thickness, which can cause uneven cooking.
- •A few reviewers noted toughness or unpleasant gristle, especially when grilled.
- •Appearance before cooking can look washed out or less appetizing compared to expectations.
- •Preparation technique greatly affects the final taste and texture—failure to prep correctly (like not scoring sinew or overcooking) can result in disappointing toughness.
- •A small portion of reviewers found the flavor lacking or the meat hard to chew.
- •Tenderness requires care, such as piercing sinew and avoiding overcooking; improper handling can lead to contraction or toughness.
Bottom Line
If you want a high-quality grass-fed, pasture-raised New York Strip steak with robust beef flavor and tender texture, this product is worth considering—especially when cooked properly with attention to temperature and seasoning. Many found it exceeds typical grocery store steaks at a reasonable price and portion size. However, there can be some variability in thickness and occasional toughness, so proper preparation is key to getting the best experience. If you want to explore other similarly sourced beef options or different cuts, *make sure to try similar grass-fed steaks that emphasize consistent thickness and marbling to ensure uniform cooking and tenderness.*
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!