Image 1 of 4
Dunlop Plastic Thumbpicks Large - Image 1
Dunlop Plastic Thumbpicks Large - Image 2
Dunlop Plastic Thumbpicks Large - Image 3
Dunlop Plastic Thumbpicks Large - Image 4
JIM DUNLOP

Dunlop Plastic Thumbpicks Large

The JIM DUNLOP 9023R Shell Plastic Thumbpicks are a solid choice for guitarists seeking a durable and responsive thumbpick. With their warm tonal qualities and enhanced control, they cater to various playing styles. However, if you are transitioning from fingerpicking or smaller picks, be prepared for a short adaptation period. Overall, these thumbpicks offer excellent value and performance for committed musicians.

Lowest at Amazon
$18.99 at Amazon
Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$18.99 at Amazon

Where to Buy

Prices last updated: April 20th 2026 3:42 pm

Product Score

Based on professional reviews and customer feedback

7.7/10
Overall
7.7
Consumer

Why this score?

The JIM DUNLOP 9023R Shell Plastic Thumbpicks receive a moderate score primarily due to their affordability and sound quality, which many users appreciate. However, frequent complaints about inconsistent sizing—particularly that the "large" picks often fit like mediums—and rapid wear of the material have left numerous customers dissatisfied. These picks might be a good option for those who value budget over longevity, but fit and durability could be dealbreakers for others.

8+ Excellent
6-8 Good
4-6 Average
<4 Poor

Score

The JIM DUNLOP 9023R Shell Plastic Thumbpicks receive a moderate score primarily due to their affordability and sound quality, which many users appreciate. However, frequent complaints about inconsistent sizing—particularly that the "large" picks often fit like mediums—and rapid wear of the material have left numerous customers dissatisfied. These picks might be a good option for those who value budget over longevity, but fit and durability could be dealbreakers for others.

7.7/10
Overall

Pros

  • Provides a warm tonal response suitable for various stringed instruments.
  • Offers increased control, especially for those who prefer using thumbpicks.
  • Comes in a 1ack, which provides great value for frequent players.
  • Made from durable plastic that ensures lonasting use and reliable performance.

Cons

  • Some players may find the large size uncomfortable, depending on finger size and playing style.
  • Possible adjustment period for those new to using thumbpicks, which might initially affect playing comfort and technique.

Bottom Line

The JIM DUNLOP 9023R Shell Plastic Thumbpicks are a solid choice for guitarists seeking a durable and responsive thumbpick. With their warm tonal qualities and enhanced control, they cater to various playing styles. However, if you are transitioning from fingerpicking or smaller picks, be prepared for a short adaptation period. Overall, these thumbpicks offer excellent value and performance for committed musicians.

Read full expert review

What Reviewers Are Saying

Praised
good quality5%
love these5%
happy with this5%
Criticized
fit is a bit tight5%
give up5%
tight and restricted my blood flow5%
quality worsened5%
not as rich a tone5%
runs small15%

Customer Ratings

372 reviews averaging 4.4 out of 5 stars from Amazon
4.4
372 reviews
5
70%
4
13%
3
11%
2
4%
1
3%

Based on 372 reviews from Amazon

Discussion

🔍About This Page

ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are updated regularly and verified for accuracy. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.

🔥 Trending Deals

Loading trending deals...