Sofft Sharnell II

Bottom Line

These boots are best for people with thicker calves and narrow feet—reviewers in this category rave about their comfort, waterproof quality, and stylish appearance. But if you have standard or wider feet, be warned: the regular-width fit often causes painful blisters, and the material scuffs easily with normal wear. The leather also starts out stiff, so you won't get maximum comfort straight away. That said, the innovative back lacing and zipper system do provide excellent customizable fit, and we recommend trying them on in person if possible, since width fit is really the deciding factor for most customers.