Image 1 of 9
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 1
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 2
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 3
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 4
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 5
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 6
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 7
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 8
NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry - Image 9
NYX

NYX Butter Lipstick - Big Cherry

$8.34across 1 retailer
Model: BLS19Color: BLS19 Big CherryUPC: 800897828059
Lowest at Amazon
$8.34 at Amazon
Lowest at any Popular Retailer
$8.34 at amazon

Pros

  • The true bright cherry red of Big Cherry matches expectations and delivers a bold, classic lipstick color.
  • Smooth, buttery soft texture that glides on comfortably without drying out lips.
  • Moist finish offers a natural, creamy look rather than a flat matte.
  • Lasts several hours and leaves a subtle, attractive stain on the lips.
  • Crueltree brand supporting ethical beauty choices.
  • Applies precisely due to the pointed lipstick shape, allowing for neat application.
  • Gentle and moisturizing formula, suitable even for sensitive or dry lips.
  • Pairs well with dark red lip liners without bleeding.
  • Offers excellent pigmentation and shade variety for the price.
  • Many users appreciated the lipstick for making a strong lip statement with a stylish black cherry/burgundy color.

Cons

  • Significant transfer occurs since the finish doesn’t dry down matte, requiring frequent toucps.
  • Leaves a noticeable stain on glasses, so careful application is advised.
  • Some color discrepancies reported, with shades appearing different (e.g., color looks more hot pink or lighter than expected).
  • May need multiple applications to build up an even, vibrant color.
  • A few users reported slight dryness, recommending exfoliation and balm use before and after application.
  • Lighter shades like nudes and pinks may not perform as well as the deeper colors.
  • Despite the lonasting claim, reapplication every 2-3 hours is necessary for full intensity.
  • Some disappointment versus hype, with users wanting to try other shades for better results.

Bottom Line

The NYX Butter Lipstick in Big Cherry offers a vibrant, moisturizing, and cruelty-free option for those craving a classic bright cherry red with a creamy finish. While it does require some upkeep due to transfer and occasional dryness, its smooth application and lasting stain make it a solid choice for a bold lip look. If you seek a truly matte and transfer-proof lipstick, you might want to explore other formulas, but for a comfortable wear with a natural sheen, this one hits the mark. Considering the price and pigmentation, it’s worth trying, especially if you like a moisturizing, easy-to-wear lipstick.

Read full expert review

Discussion

🔍About This Page

ShopSavvy compares prices across thousands of retailers so you always get the best deal. Prices are updated regularly and verified for accuracy. Our expert reviews and community discussion help you make informed buying decisions.

🔥 Trending Deals