Ben & Jerry's Half Baked

Bottom Line

We're not exaggerating when we say reviewers rave about this Half Baked flavor – there's a reason it's Ben & Jerry's best-seller. The marriage of creamy vanilla and chocolate ice cream with chunks of cookie dough and brownie pieces delivers a genuinely premium, indulgent experience that holds up beautifully even if it refreezes. That said, this is legitimately high in calories, so you'll want to think of it as an occasional treat rather than your go-to everyday scoop. If decadent ice cream is your jam and you're cool with the indulgence, this signature flavor is absolutely worth grabbing.