Best Potato Mashers for 2024

The Zyliss Stainless Steel Potato Masher stands out as our top pick for overall performance. Its robust metal mashing plate and a long, curved handle work together to make mashing effortless and comfortable. The small holes on the mashing plate ensure a consistently smooth mash, while the rounded bottom allows for easy maneuvering along the edges of your pan. Users particularly praised the comfort of the handle, which accommodates different hand sizes well. Though it’s a bit pricier than some alternatives, its exceptional durability and superior mashing capabilities make it a valuable addition to any kitchen.

Coming in as a strong runner-up, the WMF Profi Plus Potato Masher impresses with its effective performance and user-friendly design. It features a perforated oval mashing plate that smoothly navigates the edges of pans, producing consistently soft potatoes. The shorter handle does limit its reach slightly, but most users found it very comfortable to use. Although some bending was noted after extensive use, this did not detract from its overall reliability. It's a solid choice for those seeking a dependable masher with good usability.

For those on a budget, the Prepara Flip Masher delivers impressive value at an affordable price. Its innovative design includes a convex plate that utilizes a rocking motion for efficient mashing. The 73 mashing holes ensure a smooth texture, and the curved plastic handle fits most hand sizes comfortably, although it might be less ideal for larger hands. While the flipping mechanism can occasionally trap food or activate unexpectedly, these are minor issues compared to its overall performance and value. It’s a fantastic budget-friendly choice for any kitchen.

If the smoothest mashed potatoes are your goal, the OXO Good Grips Smooth Potato Masher is your best bet. This masher features a sturdy horizontal handle that is exceptionally comfortable and easy to control. While its shorter height might mean your arms could hit the edges of taller pots, its ability to produce an ultra-smooth mash is unparalleled. Built to last, this masher is perfect for anyone who prioritizes texture and consistency in their mashed potatoes.

For those with limited kitchen space, the Joseph Joseph Smasher is an excellent choice thanks to its compact design. Though it may leave some lumps in the mash and isn't the most comfortable for prolonged use, its durability is impressive. The folding handle is particularly innovative, making storage a breeze. If you're looking to save space without significantly sacrificing performance, the Joseph Joseph Smasher is a highly practical option.