Comparing Smith's HON1 Honing Solution to regular mineral oil, there are some notable differences to keep in mind. Smith's HON1 is specially crafted for sharpening, according to how the manufacturer describes it. It's a non-petroleum solution with built-in cleaning agents and rust inhibitors, so it helps prevent stones from clogging and enhances the sharpening process.
This solution is quite versatile and works on different stone types, but it really pulls its weight with Arkansas Stones and Diamond Stones. These stones need good lubrication, and Smith's HON1 gets the job done by stopping metal bits from blocking the stone's surface, which can happen if they're used dry.
Our research shows that folks often find Smith's HON1 effective for stone lubrication, leading to better sharpening. It's quite thin—kind of like water—so you might end up using more of it than you would with thicker oil-based products during a lengthy sharpening session. Users often say the results are worth it, though.
However, how well it works can vary based on the stone. For example, Diamond Stones seem to get the most out of this solution, probably because it's thin enough to spread easily across their rough surfaces. On the flip side, water stones might just absorb the solution, making it less useful since its thinness doesn't allow it to act as a barrier.
Regular mineral oil, on the other hand, is the more traditional choice when sharpening. It's thicker, which means you don't have to apply it as often, but it doesn't have the rust prevention or cleaning bonuses that Smith's HON1 offers. Ultimately, choosing between them depends on your preferences and what your sharpening setup needs.
If you want added protection and easier maintenance for specific stone types, Smith's could be a good pick. But if you're after a thicker, no-frills option, regular mineral oil should work just fine. Just think about what suits your sharpening style and stone types best.
