# TLDR Review: Watkins Butter Extract

*Published: 2025-01-21 | Updated: 2025-01-04 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/watkins-butter-extract*

---

## Product: Watkins Butter Extract
**Brand:** Watkins

## Pros
- Highly praised as an essential kitchen item for those who love the taste of butter.
- A great low-calorie alternative to traditional butter.
- Versatile ingredient that enhances a variety of dishes, including baked goods, mashed potatoes, and vegetables.
- Provides an authentic real butter flavor without added calories.
- Strong, pleasant butter scent upon opening.
- Long-standing tradition of use, with some families using Watkins Products for over 100 years.
- Tastes natural and enhances the overall flavor of dishes, avoiding a chemical taste.
- Noted as a superior choice, especially in desserts and royal icing compared to other brands.
- Offers a long shelf life with an expiration date several years out.
- Recommended as the best butter extract available.

## Cons
- The current formulation includes milk, which is disappointing for those with dietary restrictions.
- The change in formulation has led to customers deciding to stop purchasing due to dietary constraints.
- Some users express sadness over the loss of the previous milk-free formulation, impacting holiday traditions.

## Bottom Line

Watkins Butter Extract is celebrated for its authentic butter flavor and versatility in various dishes, making it a beloved staple in kitchens for generations. However, recent changes to include milk in its formulation may be a drawback for those with dietary restrictions. If you require a milk-free alternative, you may need to explore other options until a suitable substitute can be found.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Highly praised as an essential kitchen item for those who love the taste of butter. | The current formulation includes milk, which is disappointing for those with dietary restrictions. |
| A great low-calorie alternative to traditional butter. | The change in formulation has led to customers deciding to stop purchasing due to dietary constraints. |
| Versatile ingredient that enhances a variety of dishes, including baked goods, mashed potatoes, and vegetables. | Some users express sadness over the loss of the previous milk-free formulation, impacting holiday traditions. |
| Provides an authentic real butter flavor without added calories. |  |
| Strong, pleasant butter scent upon opening. |  |
| Long-standing tradition of use, with some families using Watkins Products for over 100 years. |  |
| Tastes natural and enhances the overall flavor of dishes, avoiding a chemical taste. |  |
| Noted as a superior choice, especially in desserts and royal icing compared to other brands. |  |
| Offers a long shelf life with an expiration date several years out. |  |
| Recommended as the best butter extract available. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Menards | $11.99  | Check |
| Gilbert Whitney & Co | $12.99  | Check |
| Amazon | $13.49  | Check |
| Country Kitchen SweetArt | $15.95  | Check |
| Groceryeshop | $16.27  | Check |
| Stuff From India | $26.65  | Check |
| totalhill.com | $26.81  | Check |
| GoSupps.com | $34.99  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*