# TLDR Review: Valuetoner HP 64 XL Black Ink Cartridge

*Published: 2026-06-10 | Updated: 2026-06-10 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/valuetoner-hp-64-xl-black-ink-cartridge*

---

## Product: Valuetoner HP 64 XL Black Ink Cartridge
**Brand:** Valuetoner

## Pros
- Consistently reliable performance over several years
- Provides a perfect fit for HP 7900 series and HP Envy printers
- Offers a significant cost saving, roughly half the price of OEM cartridges
- Performs as expected, meeting features and functionality described
- Ink lasts several months even with frequent printing
- Easy to install and compatible with compatible HP printers
- Offers good value for the price considering longevity and quality
- The seller’s customer service was responsive with refunds when issues arose
- Successful printing shortly after installation indicates reliable operation
- According to multiple reviews, it performs as well as more expensive HP cartridges

## Cons
- Some users reported printer rejection due to the cartridge not being recognized as genuine HP ink
- Printer messages sometimes indicated the cartridge was not authentic, blocking use
- There have been rare instances of compatibility issues with specific HP models
- A few reviews mentioned occasional inconsistent ink flow or print quality issues
- No mention of long-term performance beyond a few years in some reviews; durability beyond that time is uncertain

## Bottom Line

For those looking to save a lot on ink costs without sacrificing quality, the Valuetoner remanufactured HP 64 XL cartridge is a solid choice, especially given its good performance and longevity. However, be aware that it may trigger some printer security messages about being non-genuine, which can be managed with customer service support. If you prefer cartridges that are guaranteed to be recognized as authentic by HP, you might want to consider OEM options, but for budget-conscious users, this product offers excellent value.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Consistently reliable performance over several years | Some users reported printer rejection due to the cartridge not being recognized as genuine HP ink |
| Provides a perfect fit for HP 7900 series and HP Envy printers | Printer messages sometimes indicated the cartridge was not authentic, blocking use |
| Offers a significant cost saving, roughly half the price of OEM cartridges | There have been rare instances of compatibility issues with specific HP models |
| Performs as expected, meeting features and functionality described | A few reviews mentioned occasional inconsistent ink flow or print quality issues |
| Ink lasts several months even with frequent printing | No mention of long-term performance beyond a few years in some reviews; durability beyond that time is uncertain |
| Easy to install and compatible with compatible HP printers |  |
| Offers good value for the price considering longevity and quality |  |
| The seller’s customer service was responsive with refunds when issues arose |  |
| Successful printing shortly after installation indicates reliable operation |  |
| According to multiple reviews, it performs as well as more expensive HP cartridges |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*