# TLDR Review: Tidy Cats Clumping Cat Litter 38 lb. Box

*Published: 2025-05-04 | Updated: 2025-05-04 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/tidy-cats-clumping-cat-litter-38-lb.-box*

---

## Product: Tidy Cats Clumping Cat Litter 38 lb. Box
**Brand:** Tidy Cats

## Pros
- Clumps very well, making it an easy clean-up.
- Less dust compared to other litters, though not exactly 99% dust-free.
- No strong perfumes, and retains minimal odors post-use.
- Excellent for maintaining a clean home environment even in households with multiple cats.
- Effective at controlling odors, with no noticeable smell even with a cat that doesn't cover its waste.
- Stays in the litter box better than other brands, reducing mess around the area.

## Cons
- Heavy packaging and box design make it difficult to handle, lacking proper grips or handles.
- Pouring or scooping can be messy, with concerns about moisture affecting the cardboard in damp areas.
- Some complaints suggest it dissolves rather than clumps, and allows odors to linger.
- High tracking and less effective odor control than the original 24/7 Performance Litter.
- Recent increases in dust and decreased clumping performance compared to earlier batches.
- Clumps can bond with the surface, breaking into small pieces and creating additional clean-up work.
- Customers expressed dissatisfaction with changes to the formula and requested a return to the previous version.

## Bottom Line

While Purina Tidy Cats Clumping Cat Litter, Tidy Max 24/7 Performance is generally praised for its excellent clumping ability and odor control, the packaging and recent formula changes have left some customers disappointed. Its strong points make it still suitable for multi-cat households, but handling and clumping issues could drive users to explore other options if these are significant concerns for your household.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Clumps very well, making it an easy clean-up. | Heavy packaging and box design make it difficult to handle, lacking proper grips or handles. |
| Less dust compared to other litters, though not exactly 99% dust-free. | Pouring or scooping can be messy, with concerns about moisture affecting the cardboard in damp areas. |
| No strong perfumes, and retains minimal odors post-use. | Some complaints suggest it dissolves rather than clumps, and allows odors to linger. |
| Excellent for maintaining a clean home environment even in households with multiple cats. | High tracking and less effective odor control than the original 24/7 Performance Litter. |
| Effective at controlling odors, with no noticeable smell even with a cat that doesn't cover its waste. | Recent increases in dust and decreased clumping performance compared to earlier batches. |
| Stays in the litter box better than other brands, reducing mess around the area. | Clumps can bond with the surface, breaking into small pieces and creating additional clean-up work. |
|  | Customers expressed dissatisfaction with changes to the formula and requested a return to the previous version. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| WAM Kitchen | $14.39  | In Stock |
| DiscountToday | $23.40  | In Stock |
| DHgate online store | $26.42  | In Stock |
| Penwago Co. | $28.98  | In Stock |
| Amazon | $29.98  | In Stock |
| Petco | $29.98  | In Stock |
| Walmart | $29.98  | In Stock |
| AliExpress by Alibaba.com | $33.65  | In Stock |
| petocart.com | $36.29  | In Stock |
| I-deals.net | $39.83  | In Stock |
| I-deals.net | $39.83  | In Stock |
| Sears | $39.96  | In Stock |
| totalhill.com | $40.47  | In Stock |
| Petshopia | $41.57  | In Stock |
| Search Wellness | $76.25  | In Stock |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*