# TLDR Review: stila Stay All Day Liquid Lipstick

*Published: 2024-12-20 | Updated: 2025-02-12 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/stila-stay-all-day-liquid-lipstick*

---

## Product: stila Stay All Day Liquid Lipstick
**Brand:** stila

## Pros
- Applies easily with a wide applicator for generous coverage in one swipe.
- Comfortable and lightweight formula that feels super comfortable for long wear.
- Stunning true red shade that is universally flattering and perfect for any occasion.
- Offers incredible staying power without caking, even lasting through meals and drinks.
- Dries to a matte finish without feeling dry or uncomfortable.
- Rich pigmentation provides full coverage; color remains true throughout the day with minimal fading.
- Velvety texture applies smoothly and remains creamy for a while before setting.
- Contains nourishing ingredients like jojoba oil and pomegranate flower extract.
- High-quality, luxurious packaging that reflects the product's premium nature.
- Minimal flaking or cracking, maintaining a reliable long-lasting lip color.

## Cons
- Some users noticed crumbling and feathering, especially after meals or 12-hour wear.
- The color may resemble a Ronald McDonald red, which might not be appealing to all.
- Initial application is wet and smooth but can lead to an uncomfortably dry feel.
- Requires precise application with a mirror due to its 'paint-like' nature.
- Could be more moisturizing compared to other liquid lip products.
- Some transfer noted during eating or drinking.

## Bottom Line

The Stila Stay All Day Liquid Lipstick in Portofino is a standout among red lipsticks. It combines a universally flattering true red color with a comfortable, long-lasting wear that truly stays put throughout the day. While some may find it a tad drying and others may not favor the shade's boldness, its rich pigmentation, nourishing formula, and velvety finish make it a top choice for those seeking a day-to-night lip color that’s high on impact and comfort. If dryness is a concern, pairing it with a super glossy top coat could enhance comfort without compromising the stunning matte look.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Applies easily with a wide applicator for generous coverage in one swipe. | Some users noticed crumbling and feathering, especially after meals or 12-hour wear. |
| Comfortable and lightweight formula that feels super comfortable for long wear. | The color may resemble a Ronald McDonald red, which might not be appealing to all. |
| Stunning true red shade that is universally flattering and perfect for any occasion. | Initial application is wet and smooth but can lead to an uncomfortably dry feel. |
| Offers incredible staying power without caking, even lasting through meals and drinks. | Requires precise application with a mirror due to its 'paint-like' nature. |
| Dries to a matte finish without feeling dry or uncomfortable. | Could be more moisturizing compared to other liquid lip products. |
| Rich pigmentation provides full coverage; color remains true throughout the day with minimal fading. | Some transfer noted during eating or drinking. |
| Velvety texture applies smoothly and remains creamy for a while before setting. |  |
| Contains nourishing ingredients like jojoba oil and pomegranate flower extract. |  |
| High-quality, luxurious packaging that reflects the product's premium nature. |  |
| Minimal flaking or cracking, maintaining a reliable long-lasting lip color. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| fragrancenet.com | $14.99  | Check |
| AllBeauty.com | $15.80  | Check |
| SELFRIDGES US | $18.00  | Check |
| Walmart | $18.00  | Check |
| 11 Main | $19.70  | Check |
| eCosmetics | $19.93  | Check |
| comfortmarket.com | $21.35  | Check |
| UnbeatableSale | $21.35  | Check |
| Gilt | $21.99  | Check |
| Ruelala | $21.99  | Check |
| Zulily | $21.99  | Check |
| Luxtiques | $22.00  | Check |
| Revolve Clothing | $22.00  | Check |
| opensky | $22.45  | Check |
| SELFRIDGES US | $23.00  | Check |
| Beauty Queen Supply | $23.26  | Check |
| Sears | $23.51  | Check |
| Amazon | $24.00  | Check |
| Beauty Brands | $24.00  | Check |
| BeautyShop361.com | $24.00  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*