# TLDR Review: stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner, Dark Brown

*Published: 2025-05-26 | Updated: 2025-07-18 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/stila-stay-all-day-liquid-eyeliner-dark-brown*

---

## Product: stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner, Dark Brown
**Brand:** stila

## Pros
- Performs excellently on oily eyelids, maintaining color intensity throughout the day.
- Waterproof and smudge-proof, surviving rigorous testing and even frequent hand washing.
- Sharp felt tip allows for versatility in creating both thin and thick lines.
- Long-time favorite for many, noted for its consistency over years of use.
- Bold, super pigmented black color with a matte finish that dries quickly.
- Easy and smooth application without irritation; precision tip facilitates sharp wings.
- Trusted brand with a commitment to premium cosmetics.
- Long-wearing; doesn't require frequent touch-ups.

## Cons
- Recent formula changes have resulted in a scratchy, uneven application.
- New batches are reported to dry out quickly, leading to patchy applications.
- Difficult to create precise wings, especially for individuals with hooded eyes.
- Some users experience flaking if they rub their eyes.
- Several instances of the product being dry or ineffective upon arrival, requiring replacement.
- Many users feel the product no longer justifies its price due to these quality issues.

## Bottom Line

The stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Dark Brown is a standout product with a strong reputation for its longevity and pigmentation. However, recent changes in its formula have raised concerns among long-time users about its consistency and application quality. If you value precise application and long-lasting wear and are willing to overlook the recent issues, it remains a popular choice. For those experiencing dissatisfaction, exploring other brands might be beneficial.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Performs excellently on oily eyelids, maintaining color intensity throughout the day. | Recent formula changes have resulted in a scratchy, uneven application. |
| Waterproof and smudge-proof, surviving rigorous testing and even frequent hand washing. | New batches are reported to dry out quickly, leading to patchy applications. |
| Sharp felt tip allows for versatility in creating both thin and thick lines. | Difficult to create precise wings, especially for individuals with hooded eyes. |
| Long-time favorite for many, noted for its consistency over years of use. | Some users experience flaking if they rub their eyes. |
| Bold, super pigmented black color with a matte finish that dries quickly. | Several instances of the product being dry or ineffective upon arrival, requiring replacement. |
| Easy and smooth application without irritation; precision tip facilitates sharp wings. | Many users feel the product no longer justifies its price due to these quality issues. |
| Trusted brand with a commitment to premium cosmetics. |  |
| Long-wearing; doesn't require frequent touch-ups. |  |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Feelunique ROW | $16.92  | Check |
| AllBeauty.com | $19.15  | Check |
| Hogies Online | $19.21  | Check |
| Gilt | $20.00  | Check |
| Ruelala | $20.00  | Check |
| eCosmetics | $21.41  | Check |
| jomashop.com | $21.99  | Check |
| Dermstore | $22.00  | Check |
| Lookfantastic US | $22.00  | Check |
| SkinStore | $22.00  | Check |
| Amazon | $23.00  | Check |
| bloomingdales.com | $23.00  | Check |
| Camera Ready Cosmetics | $23.00  | Check |
| Luxtiques | $23.00  | Check |
| ModeSens | $23.00  | Check |
| Revolve Clothing | $23.00  | Check |
| Ulta Beauty | $23.00  | Check |
| opensky | $24.37  | Check |
| Groupon | $24.68  | Check |
| Worldofwatches.com | $26.98  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*