# TLDR Review: Propét Yara Mary Jane Black 8.5 X-Wide

*Published: 2026-03-03 | Updated: 2026-03-03 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/propet-yara-mary-jane-black-8.5-x-wide*

---

## Product: Propét Yara Mary Jane Black 8.5 X-Wide
**Brand:** Propét

## Pros
- Very comfortable and soft to wear, especially noted for providing extra support for sore feet
- High-quality materials and well-made construction
- Stylish Mary Jane design that appeals to many, with a neutral black color that matches various outfits
- Good fit for those needing extra room, accommodating insoles easily
- Suitable for elderly users looking for a comfortable, supportive shoe
- Users appreciate the possibility of purchasing multiple colors due to overall satisfaction

## Cons
- Runs inconsistently: some find it runs quite large and sloppy, while others say it runs narrower than expected even in X-wide, causing toe cramping
- The included sole insert is often uncomfortable and may need to be replaced
- Strong cigarette odor present out of the box that does not dissipate even with cleaning
- Velcro strap on some pairs does not stay securely fastened
- Less comfortable and less wide compared to other sneakers from the same brand

## Bottom Line

If you're searching for a stylish, comfortable Mary Jane shoe with good support and extra width, the Propét Women's Yara in Black is worth a look—especially for sensitive or elderly feet. However, be prepared for some fit inconsistencies and a strong odor initially; you might want to swap out the insoles for better comfort. If you anticipate needing a reliably wider fit without the odor issue, consider exploring other Propét models or similar supportive brands that offer a more consistent sizing experience.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Very comfortable and soft to wear, especially noted for providing extra support for sore feet | Runs inconsistently: some find it runs quite large and sloppy, while others say it runs narrower than expected even in X-wide, causing toe cramping |
| High-quality materials and well-made construction | The included sole insert is often uncomfortable and may need to be replaced |
| Stylish Mary Jane design that appeals to many, with a neutral black color that matches various outfits | Strong cigarette odor present out of the box that does not dissipate even with cleaning |
| Good fit for those needing extra room, accommodating insoles easily | Velcro strap on some pairs does not stay securely fastened |
| Suitable for elderly users looking for a comfortable, supportive shoe | Less comfortable and less wide compared to other sneakers from the same brand |
| Users appreciate the possibility of purchasing multiple colors due to overall satisfaction |  |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*