# TLDR Review: Pratt-Read Black Mulch

*Published: 2025-03-25 | Updated: 2025-03-25 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/pratt-read-black-mulch*

---

## Product: Pratt-Read Black Mulch
**Brand:** Pratt-Read

## Pros
- Highly effective and meets user expectations.
- Positive experience with the product.

## Cons
- Considered too expensive compared to similar products available elsewhere.
- Experienced fading of color within the first week.
- Product turned brown upon drying, despite being advertised as black.
- Quality of the product has significantly declined compared to previous years.
- Bags contained unshredded materials with large chunks of debris and sticks.
- Dye is used to cover up poor quality organic and inorganic waste.
- Inconsistency in quality noted, with inferior materials like cheap pine, bark, and plastic.
- Many bags were moldy, affecting quality and usability.
- Improper dyeing led to multiple bags showing brown mulch in black packaging.
- Frustration with lack of quality given the premium price.

## Bottom Line

The Pratt-Read 88502440 2Cf N.Scapes Black Mulch has faced significant criticism for its quality and price. While some users had positive experiences, many reviews highlight issues such as fading color, inconsistency, mold, and poor materials. If you are expecting 'premium' quality for the price, you might want to consider exploring other options. The considerable decline in quality and reliability suggests that looking elsewhere could be a prudent choice for your landscaping needs.

## Pros vs Cons at a Glance

| Pros | Cons |
|------|------|
| Highly effective and meets user expectations. | Considered too expensive compared to similar products available elsewhere. |
| Positive experience with the product. | Experienced fading of color within the first week. |
|  | Product turned brown upon drying, despite being advertised as black. |
|  | Quality of the product has significantly declined compared to previous years. |
|  | Bags contained unshredded materials with large chunks of debris and sticks. |
|  | Dye is used to cover up poor quality organic and inorganic waste. |
|  | Inconsistency in quality noted, with inferior materials like cheap pine, bark, and plastic. |
|  | Many bags were moldy, affecting quality and usability. |
|  | Improper dyeing led to multiple bags showing brown mulch in black packaging. |
|  | Frustration with lack of quality given the premium price. |

## Current Prices

| Retailer | Price | Availability |
|----------|-------|-------------|
| Ace Hardware | $3.33  | Check |
| Clay County Farm Supply | $4.49  | Check |
| Wilco | $4.99  | Check |
| Scheels | $5.99  | Check |
| Wilco | $5.99  | Check |
| Allendale True Value | $6.29  | Check |
| Jaeger Lumber | $6.29  | Check |
| Shell Lumber and Hardware | $6.33  | Check |
| Shell Lumber and Hardware | $6.35  | Check |
| shop.rplumber.com | $6.49  | Check |
| The Lumberyard | $6.49  | Check |
| Seed World | $6.70  | Check |
| truevalue.com | $6.79  | Check |
| jeyco.com | $6.89  | Check |
| Grange Co-op | $6.99  | Check |
| Theisen's | $6.99  | Check |
| National Supply Network | $7.51  | Check |
| MID Hardware | $8.13  | Check |
| UnbeatableSale | $8.33  | Check |
| Max Warehouse | $19.77  | Check |

---

*About this review: We pulled together findings from professional and user reviews, and cross-referenced them with ShopSavvy's pricing data from thousands of retailers to give you the short version.*