# TLDR Review: Physicians Formula Rose All Day Mascara *Published: 2024-05-09 | Updated: 2024-12-05 | Source: https://shopsavvy.com/reviews-tldr/physicians-formula-rose-all-day-mascara* --- ## Verdict The Physicians Formula Rose all day mascara offers a lovely rose scent and is praised for long-lasting wear and sensitive eye compatibility. However, its heavily scented formula and lack of volumizing effect may not appeal to everyone. For those seeking a mascara that enhances without heavy build-up and offers easy removal with oils, this could be a match. If you're looking for more volume or less fragrance, you may want to explore other options. **Top pro:** Excellent quality with no flaking, ideal for sensitive eyes. **Top con:** Very heavily scented, primarily smells like roses, which might not be for everyone. ## Product: Physicians Formula Rose All Day Mascara **Brand:** Physicians Formula [Compare prices and price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/physicians-formula-rose-all-day-mascara) ## Pros - Excellent quality with no flaking, ideal for sensitive eyes. - Buildable formula allows for customization in application. - Long-lasting wear that maintains its look throughout the day. - Easily removable with coconut oil or micellar water. - Natural composition with non-toxic ingredients. - Pleasant rose scent adds to the experience. - Does not flake off, avoiding raccoon eyes. - Holds up well during long work shifts. - Darkens lashes sufficiently to enhance eye appearance. ## Cons - Very heavily scented, primarily smells like roses, which might not be for everyone. - Stings the eyes if applied too close to the lashes. - Formula is thin and doesn't build well for volume, resulting in a thin, spider-like appearance. - Messy application; additional coats can get on eyelids. - Wand design could be improved; a curved wand is preferred. - Some users experience dryness and flaking, with dry pieces appearing under the eyes. - Requires effort to remove; less effective without a remover like coconut oil or micellar water. ## Pros vs Cons at a Glance | Pros | Cons | |------|------| | Excellent quality with no flaking, ideal for sensitive eyes. | Very heavily scented, primarily smells like roses, which might not be for everyone. | | Buildable formula allows for customization in application. | Stings the eyes if applied too close to the lashes. | | Long-lasting wear that maintains its look throughout the day. | Formula is thin and doesn't build well for volume, resulting in a thin, spider-like appearance. | | Easily removable with coconut oil or micellar water. | Messy application; additional coats can get on eyelids. | | Natural composition with non-toxic ingredients. | Wand design could be improved; a curved wand is preferred. | | Pleasant rose scent adds to the experience. | Some users experience dryness and flaking, with dry pieces appearing under the eyes. | | Does not flake off, avoiding raccoon eyes. | Requires effort to remove; less effective without a remover like coconut oil or micellar water. | | Holds up well during long work shifts. | | | Darkens lashes sufficiently to enhance eye appearance. | | ## Last Seen Prices *Each price is the last one ShopSavvy observed, on 2024-12-05; it may have changed since.* | Retailer | Price | Availability | Last seen | |----------|-------|-------------|-----------| | [Amazon](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/e5362b6d-c7ad-1a25-5c7e-14d7b20685fd?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $9.37 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Walmart](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/JnAAX2JTZYoxSPpY8NdN?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $9.98 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Dillons](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/93bb4f3f-4e52-69f8-10a7-8426aaa1f0c9?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.57 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Fred Meyer](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/98348e3d-d2e6-ef81-a26a-1cc170baff5f?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.57 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [King Soopers](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/88c526e2-e1dc-4bdc-f971-2e3b7b077497?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.57 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Kroger](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/3868bc74-d930-211d-1e75-dfd2ff16972b?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.57 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Smith's](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/b3b9a4a9-e7ff-5a42-5c2b-082bc453187a?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.57 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Instacart](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/sdWCfh3TCIGb3VANetAZ?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [Uber Eats](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/17577027-074b-976e-287a-c708cf4bb3ca?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $12.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [CTC Health](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/fd90bf06-5468-edcf-b3c3-7ed8b7d1a8ee?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $23.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | | [GoSupps.com](https://shopsavvy.com/api/redirect/products/iCaIc7hTDedBKnAsFDLl/offers/d57ef2c1-f66a-66e3-6e44-4429d3fe7559?source=shopsavvy&medium=article-review-tldr) | $29.99 | In Stock | 2024-12-05 (may have changed) | [See every retailer and the full price history on ShopSavvy](https://shopsavvy.com/products/physicians-formula-rose-all-day-mascara) --- *About this review: it summarizes the professional reviews and customer ratings ShopSavvy collected for this product, alongside prices from ShopSavvy's price data (each price shows when it was last seen).* *Machine-readable access: append `.md` to any ShopSavvy URL, or send `Accept: text/markdown`, to get this page as Markdown. For the same catalogue as structured JSON — product lookup by barcode/ASIN/URL, live prices across retailers, and price history — see ShopSavvy's MCP server at https://shopsavvy.com/agents and the Data API at https://shopsavvy.com/data.*